THE ADORNMENT OF THE SHOLAR AND
FOR THE STUDENT WHO LEARNS
The Hadeeth of Jibreel
Shaikh Saleem ibn Eed al-Hilaalee
Aboo Talhah Daawood ibn Ronald Burbank
Indeed all praise is for Allah. We praise Him and we seek
His aid and we ask for His forgiveness. We
seek Allahs refuge from the evils of ourselves and from our evil deeds. Whomsoever
no-one can misguide him and whomsoever Allaah misguides then there is none to guide him. I bear
that none has the right to be worshipped except Allaah, alone, having no partner and I bear
witness that Muhammad is His
slave and His Messenger. To proceed:
Allaah has protected the homeland of Islaam with the mujaahideen (those who fight
jihaad) and He
has protected the prescribed way of eemaan with the teachers. Since He, the Most High, says in His
It is not right for the Believers that all of them should go off to battle.
Rather from every troop of them
some of them should remain in order that
they should attain knowledge in the Religion. That they should warn their
when they return to them so that they can beware of evil. [Soorah at-Tawbah
So Allaah, the Perfect, placed
the Believers into two groups. On one of them He has made it
obligatory that they fight jihaad in His way. And upon the
other one, He has made it obligatory that
they attain knowledge of His Religion, in order that not all of them go off
to fight jihaad. Because if
they all went off to fight jihaad, then the prescribed laws would pass away and knowledge
pass away. Then it would not be possible for them to seek knowledge after that and so the
therefore gain dominance over the Religion. Thus, Allaah has raised up high the
levels of the two groups of people.1 And
the great scholar Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah (may Allaah have
mercy on him) said in his book, Miftaah Daaris-Sa'aadah, [vol.1,
pp.50~51]. "And Allaah, the Perfect,
has informed in His Book about the raising high of the levels four times. The first
of them is His
O you who believe, when it is said to you to make space in the gatherings,
then make space
such that Allaah may grant you spacious dwellings in
Paradise and if it is said to you, `Arise,' then rise up. Allaah
will raise up
those of you who have Eemaan and those of you who have knowledge in
ranks. And Allaah is fully aware
of whatever you do. [Soorah al-Mujaadilah
The second aayah is His saying:
The Believers are only those
who, when Allaah is mentioned, their hearts
tremble with fear. And when His signs are recited to them, it increases
in Eemaan and they depend upon their Lord. They are those who
establish the prayer and spend out of that which Allaah
has provided for
them. They are the true Believers, they have ranks with their Lord and
they have forgiveness and
generous provision in Paradise from their Lord.
[Soorah al-Anfaal (6):2~4].
And the third aayah is the saying of Allaah,
the Most High:
And whomever comes to Allaah as a true Believer, having done righteous
and correct deeds, then for
them there are the high ranks. [Soorah Taa Haa
1 Taken from the introduction of Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih,
the book of al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee, and has been adapted
And the fourth aayah is the saying of Allaah, the Most
Indeed Allaah has preferred the ones who fight jihaad over those who sit,
with a very great reward: degrees
of higher grades from Him and
forgiveness and mercy. [Soorah an-Nisaa (4):95~96].
So these are four places. In three
of them, the raising up of the ranks is for the people of Eemaan,
that is those who have the beneficial knowledge (al-'ilm
un-naafi') and righteous and correct action
(al-'amalus-Saalih). And the fourth aayah mentions the raising up of ranks
due to jihaad. So all of
the aayahs about the raising up of ranks refer back to knowledge and jihaad, which are the two
supports of this Religion."
And from this we see that the scholars, (who have the correct knowledge and wisdom, and
people the knowledge in such a manner that they teach them the easy things first and then the
those by whom the proof is established, and by whose sayings doubts are removed in
the sittings of knowledge and whose
sittings are fields where the souls are purified, and in the fields
of calling to Allaah-(we see) that they are like those
fighting jihaad in the way of Allaah, those who
rebut the enemy and those who cut off the desires of the Unbelievers,
who go to the battlefronts
defending the frontiers.
And this understanding is reported from a group of the first Salaf,
Abud-Dardaa (radiyallaahu 'anhu)
said, "Whoever holds that going off in the morning or going off later in the day to gain
knowledge is not jihaad, then he is deficient in his intellect and deficient in his opinion."
And Ka'b al-Ahbaar
said, "The student of knowledge is like the one who goes off in the morning, or
later in the day to fight in the way of
Allaah, the Mighty and the Majestic."
And Sufyaan ibn Uyainah al-Hilaalee said, "Whoever seeks knowledge then he has pledged
allegiance to Allaah."2
"Indeed some of them, may Allaah have mercy upon them, have clearly stated, amongst them Maalik,
ash-Shaafi'ee and Imaam Ahmad, and it is stated word for word by Aboo Haneefah - that, `... the
most excellent of
actions, after the obligatory duties, is seeking knowledge." This saying is
witnessed to by the saying of the Messenger
of Allaah (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam), The excellence of
knowledge is greater than optional actions and the best of
your religion is piety. [Sahih at-Targheeb wat-Targheeb,
And Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah (may Allaah have mercy
on him) said in Miftaah Daaris-Sa'aadah,
commenting upon this hadeeth, "This speech is the decisive saying in this matter
because if it is the
case that some knowledge and an action are both obligatory, then they must both be done, such as
fasting and prayer. In that case the excellence of knowledge, optional knowledge is better than the
extra and optional worship. This is because the benefit of knowledge is general, it
benefits its possessor and it benefits
the rest of the people as well. Whereas the benefit of worship is
particular to the person who does that worship. Also
because with the scholar, his benefit and
knowledge remains after his death. Whereas worship is cut off from him at his
And just as it is the case that the one fighting jihaad cannot repel an enemy except with a weapon
his being prepared, then whoever wishes to go out to fight, has to make preparation for
that. Just as Allaah, the Most
If they had truly wanted to go out to fight, they would have made
preparation for it. [Soorah at-Tawbah
2 Refer to `Madaarijas-Salikeen,' vol.2, p.470.
3 Is is rather Sahih at-Targheeb wat-Tarheeb, no.65.
And therefore He has commanded that those fighting jihaad
prepare and make ready, so He said:
And prepare and make ready for them whatever strength you are able to.
So likewise, the scholar, the teacher and the student will not be able to achieve anything nor
any distress, nor will he be able to remove any darkness except by his having fine character
and correct manners. So it
is befitting that the scholar and the teacher should stand out and likewise
the student who is learning. He should be
distinguished and stand out from the ways of the common
people by the fact that he applies the narrations of the Messenger
of Allaah (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) as
far as he is able. By applying the matters of the Sunnah upon himself because
Allaah, the Exalted
and Most High, said:
Indeed there is in Allaah's Messenger an excellent and fine example for
[Soorah al-Ahzaah (33):21].
And all praise is for Allaah, who has caused Sufyaan ath-Thawree to say a very fine word.
"If you are able that you should not even scratch your head except according to a narration, then do
4 "And how truthfully the person who spoke has said, `Whoever is not trained and watered by
the Messenger and given fine
milk to drink by him, then he is a lost child deprived of his lineage and
he will not get beyond the behaviour of his
own people." In this there is an explanation of what has
preceded, that the authentic, prophetic Sunnah, in all its entirety
contains all the manners required
by the teacher and by the student.
They are contained and they are gathered in the
authentic Sunnah. Indeed even further, I have
found all of that stored or held within the long hadeeth of Jibreel concerning
and Ihsaan." These manners are contained within the words of this one hadeeth, because in its
there are the methodologies of teaching and there are pearls in that regard. In its shade are
the ways to be followed,
when learning and there are precious lessons in that.
So I saw that they should be extracted and affirmed in order that
they should be brought out as a
golden chain leading to lofty and pure manners. As a reminder of the lofty and pleasing
should be adopted, in order that the ummah of Islaam should come back to being, the best of the
I have called it The Adornment of the Scholar and the Teacher and Sufficiency for the
Student who learns from the
hadeeth of Jibreel (alaihis-salaam). And I hope from Allaah that He
causes it to produce fruits and He causes it to reach
those who deserve it. Those who when they find
some good, make supplication for good and blessing for the author of a
book and for the publisher
of a book. And if they find any shortcomings in it, they rectify and they advise. But as for
people who lie in wait then whenever they see a slip, cry out and shout aloud, just like hyenas. And
Allaah for a good end, and it is for Allaah to direct us upon the way.
Written by the one praising his Lord for the completion
of His Favour and sending blessings and
peace upon Allaah's Messenger for the ease of his Sunnah and the clarity of his
Aboo Usaama Saleem ibn Eed al-Hilaalee, as-Salafee, al-Atharee in 'aqeedah, in manhaj, in
methodology and in
the details of the way.
The forenoon of the day of Jumuah, in the middle of Jumaadal-Oolaa, of the year
the hijrah of our Messenger, our example Muhammad ibn Abdullah
(sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) in 'Ammaan, al-Balqaa, the
capital of Jordan.
4 Reported in Al-Jaami' li-Akhlaaq ar-Raawee wa Aadaahis Saami', volume 1, page 142.
THE LONG HADEETH OF JIBREEL
From 'Umar ibn al-Khattaab (radiyallaahu 'anhu) who
said, Whilst we were sitting
with Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) one day when a man came to us
clothes were extremely white and whose hair was extremely black; no
trace of his having travelled could be seen upon him
and none of us knew him.
So he sat down with the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam), and he put his two
his (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) two knees, and he put his two hands on
his two (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) thighs.
He said, `O Muhammad! Inform me
about al-Islaam.' So Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said, `Islaam
that you testify that none has the right to be worshipped except Allaah and
that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allaah,
that you establish the Prayer,
that you give the Zakat and that you fast Ramadan and that you make Hajj to
if you are able to get there.' He said, `You have spoken the truth.'
So we were surprised with him, asking him and (then)
telling him that he had
spoken the truth. `Then inform me about Eemaan.' He said, `Eemaan is that
you truly believe
in Allaah and His Angels and His Books and His Messengers
and the Last Day and that you truly believe in the Pre-decree
(Qadr), the good
of it and the evil of it.' He said, `You have spoken the truth. Then tell me
about Ihsaan.' He said,
`It is that you worship Allaah as if you are seeing Him
and even though you do not see him, yet He certainly sees you.'
He said, `You
have spoken the truth.' He said, `Then tell me about the Last Hour.' He said,
`The one who is questioned
about it does not know any better than the one who
is asking.' He said, 'Then inform me about its signs.' He said, `That
girl will give birth to her mistress and that you will see the bare-footed, naked
and destitute shepherds
of sheep competing to build high buildings.' Then he
went off, so he (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) remained for some time
and then he
said to me, `O 'Umar! Do you know who the questioner was?' I said, `Allaah
and His Messenger know best.'
He said, `This was Jibreel-he came to you to
teach you your Religion.'
Authenticity of the Hadeeth
is from the singular narrations of Muslim, which are not reported by al-Bukhaaree. So
Muslim reports it in his Saheeh,
number 8, by way of Ibn 'Umar who said, "My father, 'Umar,
narrated this to me ...' It is reported by Ibn 'Umar from the
Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) as occurs
in Majma'az-Zawa'id (1 /40), at-Tirmidhee said in his Sunan (8/5), "And
what is correct is Ibn 'Umar
from his father, 'Umar from the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam)." It is also reported
by the two
Shaykhs, al-Bukhaaree in Al-Fath, 1/114, and Muslim, number 9, from the hadeeth of Aboo Hurairah
'anhu). An-Nasaa'ee reports it (8/101) from the hadeeth of Aboo Hurairah and Aboo
Dharr (radiyallaahu 'anhu). I say: His
chain of narration is authentic (saheeh).
And the hadeeth of 'Umar from the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) is also
related from a group of the
Companions (radiyallaahu 'anhum): from Ibn 'Abbaas, Anas ibn Maalik, Jareer ibn 'Abdullaah
'Aamir or Aboo Maalik al-Ashja'ee. I say: However their
chains of narration are not free from
criticism. They are, however, suitable for consideration.
Importance of this
Ibn Rajab al-Hanbalee (may Allaah have mercy on him) said in his book Jaami'ul'Uloom wal-Hikam 5
this hadeeth, "And it is a hadeeth that is very great in importance and comprises an
explanation of the whole of the Religion.
Therefore the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said at the
end of it, this was Jibreel, he came to you to teach you
your Religion ... saying this after he had
explained the level of Islaam and Eemaan and Ihsaan, so he declared all of
that to be the Religion,
And he said,7 "So whoever considers what we have indicated regarding what this
very great hadeeth
indicates will find that all matters of knowledge and all matters concerning awareness of the
come back to this hadeeth and they enter under it. Also that the knowledge of all of the
scholars in the groups of this
ummah, which they speak about does not fall outside this hadeeth and
what this hadeeth shows in general or in particular.
Because the scholars of fiqh speak about matters of worship that are from the affairs of Islaam, and
they add onto
that some matters from the rulings on matters of wealth, matters of marriage and
matters pertaining to blood and all of
that is from the knowledge of Islaam, as has already been
But there remains much from the knowledge of
Islaam, from its manners and from its characteristics
and so on which they do not speak about except for a few of them.
And they do speak about the
meaning of the two shahaadahs, when they are the foundation of all of Islaam. And those who
speak about the fundamentals of the religion, speak about the two shahaadahs and about Eemaan in
Allaah, His Angels,
His Books, His messengers and the Last Day and Eemaan in the Predecree
(Qadr). All of that being mentioned in this hadeeth.
And those who speak about matters of awareness of the heart and matters of relations with the
people speak about the
level of ihsaan, and they speak about matters that are inward, which enter
into what is eemaan also, such as fear, love
and dependence and being pleased, having patience
and so on. All of that enters into eemaan. So all branches of knowledge
of the sharee'ah which the
people in the different groups of Muslims speak about, enter into this hadeeth and all of them
back to it. So in this hadeeth alone there is sufficiency and all praise is for Allaah and all blessings
I say: And therefore this hadeeth is counted from those ahaadeeth which the whole of Islaam rests
and are the pillar and the support of Islaam. And in this treatise which you see in front of you
there is sufficient proof
of what has been said in this regard.
5 Page 54 of its abridgement.
6 The origin of this saying is taken from Ibn
Taymiyyah in Al'Uboodiyyah, pages 24~25. And the earlier scholars if they
adapted someone's words, either by addition,
deletion or abridgement did not see it to be necessary to then quote the
original source. But in this age we suffer from
young upshoots who have little knowledge, and cause trouble to the people of
knowledge, thinking themselves to be upon
something, when this is not the case. So they make great accusations in this
regard against the wise scholars of this
ummah and those upon their way - this only shows their own foolishness. So for a
time I applied the methodology of the
earlier scholars in this regard. And some of those who turn into raisins before having
ripened into grapes, those who
do not have the patience to study long works and to compare sayings may think our saying
that this was a methodology followed
by the earlier scholars is an exaggeration. But I have gathered more than a thousand
clear examples of this matter - from
most of the earlier and later scholars, and have come across witnesses to that given by
the verifiers from the people
of knowledge. But then it seemed better to me not to act upon that in these times when the
people are satisfied with the
smell of knowledge alone and not its taste. So this is a case of `speak to the people according to
the level of their
understanding,' and Allaah, the Most High, knows best. The matter requires further clarification that you will
Allaah wills, in some of our articles published in our publication Al-Asaalah. And our shaykh, the great scholar, the
and scholar of fiqh, Aboo 'Abdur-Rahmaan al-Albaanee (may Allaah have mercy on him) has the merit of having
and clarified this, so may Allaah reward him with good.
7 Page 73 of the abridgement.
THE GARDENS OF PARADISE
In the saying of 'Umar ibn al-Khattab (radiyallaahu
'anhu), "Whilst we were sitting " is a proof of the
importance of the gatherings of knowledge.
is fitting that the people of knowledge set up gatherings for teaching the people because this is
the highest level of
rabbaaniyeen [the scholars who are wise and teach the people in a wise
manner]. As the Lord of all creation said:
is not (possible) for any human being to whom Allaah has given the Book
and al-Hukma (the knowledge and understanding
of the laws of religion
etc.,) and Prophethood to say to the people, `Be my worshippers rather
than Allaah's.' On
the contrary (he would say), `Be Rabbaaniyoon (learned
men of religion who practice what they know and also teach and
others).' Because you are teaching the Book, and you are studying it. [Soorah
was something informed by the truthful and trustworthy Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam)
when he said, "Whoever relieves
from a believer some distress from the distresses of this world, Allaah
will relieve from him some of the distress from
the distress o f the Day o f Resurrection. And whoever
makes it easy for a person in hardship then Allaah will make it
easy for him in this world and the Hereafter.
And whoever covers up something for a Muslim then Allaah will cover up his
faults in this world and the
Hereafter. And Allaah aids a servant as long as the servant is aiding his brother. And whoever
a path by which he seeks knowledge then Allaah will make easy for him a path to Paradise. And no
gather in one of the houses of the houses of Allaah reciting the Book of Allaah and studying it
amongst themselves except
that tranquility descends upon them, and mercy covers them, and the Angels
surround them, and Allaah mentions them to
those in His presence. And whoever is such that his actions keep
him back 8 then his lineage will not hasten him forward."9
Along with the fact that this practice contains the beauty of the Religion, and it also involves
following the way
laid down by the Salafus-Saalih, from the first and foremost. Because a group of
the scholars who acted upon knowledge
used to establish circles for hadeeth and circles for fiqh.
Such as Imaam Maalik ibn Anas, Shu'bah ibn al-Hajjaaj, Yazeed
ibn Haaroon, Muhammad ibn
Ismaa'eel al-Bukhaaree, Ahmad ibn Hanbal and others (may Allaah have mercy on them all).
i.e., he falls short, or his actions are deficient.
9 Reported by Muslim (no.2699) from the hadeeth of Aboo Hurairah (radiyallaahu
Specifying the Gathering of Knowledge
It is befitting
that the scholar who teaches should specify for the students the day for the gathering,
so that they do not have to break
away from and disrupt their work in order to come to it. And some
of them should remind others of it.
Appropriate time and not tiring the People
The gathering for knowledge should not be every day, because that will cause
the students to
become weary. The proof in this regard is what is established from 'Abdullaah ibn Mas'ood
'anhu). So it is reported from Aboo Waa'il, who said, Abdullaah used to give admonition
to the people on every Thursday.
So a man said to him, O Aboo 'Abdur-Rahmaan, I would love that
you gave an admonition to us every day. So he replied,
What prevents me from doing that is that I
hate that. I should bore you. Rather I give it to you at certain times just
as the Prophet (sallallahu
alayhi wa sallam) used to give it to us at certain times-for fear that he would make us fed
And if a person wants to do very much, then it should be three times each week. From Ikrimah,
Ibn 'Abbaas (may Allaah have be pleased with them both) who said, "Narrate to the people once
every week, and if you refuse
then twice and if you do it a lot then three times. And do not
make the people fed up with this Qur'aan and do not come
to a people when they are speaking with
some of their talk such that you start to relate to them and cut off their talk
and therefore bore
them, but remain silent. So when they ask you then narrate to them, such that they are eager, and
rhymed prose when making supplication. Because I experienced that Allaah's Messenger
(sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) and
his Companions didn't do this, rather they only avoided it."11
And al-Bayhaqee in his hook, Al-Madkhal ilas-Sunanil-Kubraa
(pp.357~361), brings a chapter
heading in this regard: Chapter - Suitable Times for Admonition and Knowledge - for fear
the people ... in it he reports a number of narrations from the Salafus-Saalih.
in his book, Al-Jaami li Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadaabis-Saami (2/127),
brings a chapter heading: The Hatred of Boring the
Listener and of Tiring him out by quoting
hadeeth for a long time and quoting very much ... He says in that chapter, It
is befitting that the
narrator of hadeeth should not make the gathering in which he is narrating very long. Rather he
should make it moderate in length and of middle length to avoid making the one who is listening fed
up and weary;
such as will lead him to become weary and lazy about learning.
Then he reports from al-Mubarrid, that he said, "Whoever
makes the speech long and speaks a
great deal, then he has exposed his companions to the risk of boredom and not listening
That he leaves a remainder of his hadeeth to return to another time is better for him than adding
which is essential for the student to hear, at a time when he has no desire and no energy
to do so. It is reported from
'Abdullaah ibn al-Mu'tazz that he said, From the narrators of hadeeth
there are some who make it such that the people
can hear and listen well and who avoid causing
boredom. And they do so by making it somewhat short and they make it longer
if they see that the
people's eyes want extra. He is a person who knows how to join sayings and cut things off at the
right place. He knows what to quote and what to indicate. This is something which adorns his
manners just as his manners
adorn him. As is well known naturally a person who is listening
becomes bored more quickly than the person speaking and
the hearts become tired just as the
bodies become tired.
Therefore it is recommended to make use of various points
of wisdom to make it easy for the hearts
of the people. As is reported from the famous taabi'ee, az-Zuhree, `A man used
to sit with the
Companions of Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) and he would revise narrations with
But when the hadeeth became too much for him and difficult for him, he would say, `The ear
10 Reported by al-Bukhaaree,
Eng.Trans.Vol. 1, p.60 and Muslim, no.2821.
11 Reported by Al-Bukhaaree, Eng. Trans. Vol.8, p.234, no.349.
becomes tired even though the heart desires it. So give
me some of your poetry and give me some
of your worldly talk."12 Therefore when az-Zuhree was asked about the hadeeth
he would say,
Cause yourselves to desire it by using worldly talk. 13 Muhammad ibn 'Abdul-Wahhab,14 said, `This
because the word az-Zuhree used (i.e., amhidoona) means when camels go outside and eat the
nice juicy green plants and
then they become sick of it, they eat that which is bitter and thorny and
keep eating it until they become fed up and
bored with that-then they desire the fresh one again,
and so go back to the fresh one. Therefore it is said, `amhidoonaa'
means `mix up your hadeeth
with something that it not hadeeth' so that the soul becomes ready and eager."'
of the Salaf upon the gatherings of knowledge
And it is fitting upon the student who is learning that he should keenly
attend the gatherings of
knowledge and that he should eat from its gardens, just as was encouraged by the Imaam of the
pious ones, the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam). He (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said, When one of you
by the gardens of Paradise then take from them The Companions said, "And what are the
gardens of Paradise, O Messenger
of Allaah?" So he said, The circles of Remembrance. Because
Allaah, the Most High, has Angels who travel around seeking
out the gatherings of Remembrance, so
when they come upon them they surround them.
15 So when the scholar and the
teacher have laid
down a day for the students, it is not fitting that anyone should keep away from that appointment
he is prevented from it with something sufficient as an excuse.
The Salaf, those who came before us in knowledge and eemaan
were extremely eager and keen for
knowledge and the gatherings of knowledge, because the scholar of this ummah and the
explainer of the Qur'aan, Ibn 'Abbaas (radiyallaahu 'anhu), himself used to come to the doors of the
in the hottest part of the day just to ask them about a hadeeth, which will, if Allaah
wills, be shown later in the book.
Indeed one of them would be such that a hadeeth would pass him
by and due to that he would become sick and so ill that
he would have to stay in bed, as happened
to Shu'bah ibn al-Hajjaaj (may Allaah have mercy on him). He said, "I sit for
revising hadeeth and if I
find that I have missed one, I become ill."16
The Salaf used to crowd around the gatherings
of knowledge to such an extent that the reason why
Hushaim (may Allaah have mercy on him) died was due to the crowding
of the students upon him. As
al-Khattaabee (may Allaah have mercy on him) said, "The students of hadeeth crowded and crushed
around Hushaim to such a degree that they crushed him against his donkey and this was the cause
of his death,"17 and
"It would happen that they would run in the pathways in order to meet the
gatherings of knowledge, as Shu'bah ibn al-Hajjaaj
(may Allaah have mercy on him) said, `I have not
seen anyone ever who runs except that I would say he is a crazy man or
he is a student of
hadeeth.' 18 Whoever knows the excellence of knowledge and its delight will never cease to seek an
increase in that, he will always be keen upon that knowledge and he will be insatiable. Just as
(sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said, "There are two avid ones who crave and cannot be
satisfied: one who craves knowledge
and he will not be satisfied, and one who craves this world and
he will not be satisfied." 19
12 Reported by al-Khateeb
al-Baghdaadee in Al-Jaami' li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadaabis-Saami' (2/129/130), and by al-Bayhaqee
in Madkhal ilas-Sunanil-Kubraa
13 Ibid., (2/130) and (no.607) in Al-Madkhal.
14 One of the narrators of the hadeeth of az-Zuhree.
A hadeeth that is hasan due to its supports, as I have clarified in Saheeh Kitaabil-Adhkaar wa da'eefih, (4/4).
Ashaabil-Hadeeth, (page 115).
17 Quoted in AL-'Uzlah, (p.101).
18 Al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee in Al-Jaami' li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee
wa Aadaabis-Saami' (1/152).
19 Reported by al-Haakim (1/92) and al-Bayhaqee in Madkhal ilas-Sunanil-Kubraa (no.451) by
way of Qataadah, from Anas.
It was declared saheeh to the standard of the two shaykhs by al-Haakim, and adh-Dhahabee agreed.
However our Shaykh
commented in correction of their saying in his annotation upon Al-Mishkaat (no.260), saying, Its weakness
is that Qataadah
is a mudallis and narrates with 'an'anah (i.e., failing to state clearly that he heard it directly from
the person he named.
[Trans. note]). But it has another chain of narration from Hammaad ibn Muslim, from Humayd, from
Anas. This is reported by
al-Bayhaqee in Shu'abul-Eemaan (no.10279) and in Madkhal ilas-Sunanil-Kubraa (no.450) and Ibnul-Jawzee
in al Ilalul-Mutanaahiyah
(no.113) and Ibn Adiyy in Al-Kaamil (6/2298). I say, Its chain of narration contains weakness,
as declared by
Ibn 'Adiyy and Ibn al-Jawzee.
KNOWLEDGE IS TO BE COME
The description of 'Umar ibn al-Khattaab (radiyallaahu
'anhu) that they, `... were sitting with Allaah's
Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) ...' and his saying, `... when
a man came to us ...' contains a
proof that the scholar is to be come to in his gathering. Because from the right of the
scholar is that
the people should come to him and not that he should go to them. Therefore it is befitting upon the
that he should preserve his honour and should raise himself above proceeding to the house
of those who want knowledge,
because this is humiliation for the knowledge and is degrading for
that knowledge that the scholar, who is the teacher,
has to take it and carry it to the house of the
student who is learning. So those Companions (radiyallaahu 'anhum) were
not too proud to come to the
gatherings of knowledge, and likewise Jibreel (alaihis-salaam) he came to it, to educate
Companions (radiyallaahu 'anhum) and as an indication for them of the right of knowledge upon the
was the way proceeded upon by the Salaf (radiyallaahu 'anhum). From Ibn 'Abbaas (radiyallaahu
'anhu) who said, "When Allaah's
Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) was taken in death, I said to a
man from the Ansaar, `Come let us go and 'ask
questions from the Companions of Allaah's
Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) because today they are many.' So he
said, `How surprising for
you, Ibn 'Abbaas, do you see the people having a need of you whilst among the people there are
many of the Companions of Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) So that person left this
idea, but I went
and I asked questions of the Companions of Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa
sallam). I asked them about the ahaadeeth,
so that whenever I would hear that a man had a
hadeeth, I would go to his door and if he was having a siesta (Qayloolah),
20 I would lay down at his
door and the wind would scatter dust upon me so he would come out and say, `O son of the uncle
of Allaah's Messenger! What has brought you here? Why didn't you send a message to me that I
should come to you?'
So he said, `There is more right upon me that I should come to you and ask
you about the hadeeth.' He said, `Therefore
that man of the Ansaar who didn't ask, lived until he
saw me and the people had gathered around me asking me questions.'
And the man of the Ansaar
said, `This young man was more intelligent than me."' 21 This was taken on by the taabi'een
those who followed them upon good, continuing until Imaam Maalik (may Allaah have mercy on him) said
saying, whose fame has spread far and wide, "Knowledge is to be come to, it does not
come to you."
20 i.e., sleeping
at the time of the midday heat and it is a Sunnah of the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) due to the
saying of Allaah's
Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam), "Have siesta because the devils do not have siesta," and it is a
is hasan brought by Shaykh al-Albaanee in Silsilatus-Saheehah, no. 1647.
21 Reported by al-Haakim and al-Bayhaqee in his
Madkhal ilas-Sunan (no. 673) and al-Khateeb in his excellent book Al-Jaami'
li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadabaais-Saami' (1/158~159)
(106~107), (The Book Gathering the Manners of the Narrator and
the Manners of those who listen to the Narrations). Also
collected by Ibn 'Abdul-Barr in Jaami' Bayaanil-'Ilm wa Fadlihi
(1/85), and concerning this narration al-Haakim said,
"... and it is a fundamental principle with regard to seeking
hadeeth and giving respect to the muhaddith." And I say:
in this narration there are contained the manners for the
students and from these manners are:
(i) Not causing hardship
to the shaykhs in other than the time of the gathering and not troubling
them in their free time and in their private
times, and the time for their families and in time of
(ii) The excellence of seeking knowledge at a
young age. That it is more useful and beneficial to
do that. So how much the students of knowledge need to bring on board
these manners that are
good and pleasing and take on these manners of eemaan, so that they can return as the model
the revival of the scholarly knowledge based salafee call.
Preserving the Honour of Knowledge and Respecting it
in this way, the people of knowledge preserved the honour of knowledge-so it was a preservation
of their honour. They
caused it to be something that they respected and gave honour to, so it
became an honour for them and how truly 'Alee
ibn Abdul-'Azeez al-Jurjaanee spoke when he said:
"The people say to me that, `You withdraw and
keep away from the
But what they have seen is just a man who
keeps away from humiliation.
I see that the people sire such
that whoever is
close to them,
Then he is held in contempt by them,
And whoever has respect for his own self then
he is the noble one.
I have not ceased keeping aloof from the people
with my honour to one side,
from fault finding as a safeguard,
And I regard it as profit to do so.
I would not have fulfilled the right of knowledge
if every time a desire appeared before me, I used
knowledge as a ladder to climb upon to attain it.
If it is said
to me, `There is a watering place
Then I will say, `I can see it.'
However the soul of the free person
can pot up
with being thirsty.
Every burst of lightning that appears in front of
me does not excite me,
I am not pleased that I should take
everyone from the people of the earth as
I have not expended
my soul in the service of
In order that I should be a servant to whoever I
I should be served.
Did I go through straitened circumstances for it,
in order to plant and establish it
have to harvest humiliation as a result
In that case following ignorance would have been
wiser for me.
If the people of knowledge had only preserved
the honour of knowledge
It would have preserved their honour.
they had given it honour in the hearts of the
people it would have been honoured.
But they debased it and therefore
And they (disfigured it due to their own greedy
So that its appearance looked
ugly. " 22
22 Refer necessarily to Al-Jaarni' li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadaabaais Saami (1/371) and Yateematud Dahr (4/23).
And coming to the people of knowledge in their gatherings
shows honour and respect for the
knowledge, just as Ma'mar said, "I heard az-Zuhree say, `I used to come to the door of
az-Zubair and I would sit there waiting, but then I would go off not having entered upon him. But if
had wanted to I could have entered. Out of honour and respect for him."23 This matter causes
pleasure to the souls of
the bearers of knowledge. So from Ibn 'Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with them
both) who said, "I found most of the knowledge
of Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) with
this small group of the Ansaar. I would have my siesta outside
the door of one of them, and if I had
wanted to get permission to enter, he would have easily granted me permission to
enter, but I
sought through that to seek his good pleasure.24
Beware of the Doors of the Rulers
deserves to be pointed out at this place is that the people of knowledge should keep
away from the door of the ruler.
Sufyaan ath-Thawree (may Allaah have mercy on him) said in the advice
which he gave to 'Abbaad,25 "And beware of the rulers,
of drawing close to them and of mixing with
them in anything from the affairs. Beware of being fooled so that it is said
to you, `Intercede with
them, and repel some harm from a person being oppressed ... or help one being oppressed to
his right,' because this is one of the deceptive traps of Iblees. And it is something which the
evil reciters use ors
a means for their own benefit."
Ibn al-Jawziyy (may Allaah have mercy on him) said in Talbees Iblees (pp. 121~122), "And
deceptions of Iblees upon the scholars is their mixing with the rulers and the kings, their flattering
and failure to correct them when they are able to do so. Maybe they make allowances for them
where there is no allowance
for them, in order to attain some worldly benefit. So this produces
corruption from three angles.
Firstly, the ruler
is corrupted by that. He says, `If I were not upon what is correct, the scholar
would correct me. And how can I not be
correct when he is eating from my wealth?!'
Secondly, the common person because he says, `There is no harm in this ruler,
nor in his
wealth, nor in his actions, because such and such scholar, does not criticise him.'
Thirdly, the scholar
(himself) is corrupted by that. Because he corrupts his religion through this
practice, and Iblees has deceived them into
entering upon the rulers by saying to them, `You will
just enter to intercede for the benefit of a Muslim.' This deception
is uncovered by the fact that if
somebody besides him were to enter upon the ruler instead that would not please him.
conclusion, entering upon the rulers contains very great danger. Because the intention
may be good at the beginning
then it may change due to the fact that the rulers honour
them and bestow gifts upon them or due to the fact that they
start having desires for
what they possess, and so he becomes unable to prevent himself from flattering them,
abandons correcting them. Sufyaan ath-Thawree (may Allaah have mercy on him) said, `I do not
fear about the rulers humiliating
me. Rather what I fear from them is that they should honour me,
so that my heart should incline towards them.'"
Rajab al-Hanbalee said in his book, Sharh Hadeethidh-Dhi`baan (the hadeeth about the two
hungry wolves), "Many of the
salaf used to forbid entry upon the rulers even for those who wanted
to go to command them with good and to forbid them
from evil. From those who forbade this were
'Umar ibn Abdul-'Azeez, Ibn al-Mubaarak, ath-Thawree and others. Ibn al-Mubaarak
said, `The one
who commands and forbids them in our view is not the one who enters upon them and commands
them. Rather the one who commands and forbids them is the one that keeps away from
them.' The reason for this is what
is to be feared from the trial of entering upon them. Because a
person's soul may give an individual the false impression,
when he is far away from them, that he
23 Reported by Aboo Nu'aim in Al-Hilyah (3/362), al-Bayhaqee in his Madkhal ilas-Sunan
(no. 675) and al-Khateeb in
Al-Jaamii' il-Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadaabaais-Saami' (1 / 159).
24 Reported by Aboo Khaythamah
in Al-Ilm (no. 133) and al-Bayhaqee in Madkhal ilas-Sunan (no. 674) and al-Khateeb in
Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih (2/142)
and also in Al-Jaamii' il-Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadaabaais-Saami' (1 / 159).
25 This is a comprehensive and well-known piece
of advice. It is advice involving manners, wisdom, matters of admonition
and examples and it is something well-known and
well-read by the people of knowledge. I have commented upon and
explained it in my book Min Wasaayas-Salaf, pages 19~25.
will order them and forbid them and be severe with them.
But when he sees them from nearby, then
his soul inclines towards them, because love of honour is something hidden within
the souls. So he
flatters them and is mild with them, he may even incline towards them and love them, particularly if
they treat him with kindness and honour and he accepts that from them. This occurred with
'Abdullaah ibn Taawoos along
with one of the rulers in the presence of his father, Taawoos. So
Taawoos rebuked his son for this. Sufyaan ath-hawree
wrote to 'Abbaad ibn 'Abbaad and in the
letter he wrote, `Beware of the rulers, beware of drawing close to them or mingling
with them in
anything from the affairs."
And the great scholar of Andalus, Ibn 'Abdul-Barr (may Allaah have mercy
on him) said in his book,
Jaami' Bayaanil-Ilm (1 / 185~186) at the end of the chapter in which he mentioned how the Salaf
used to criticise entry upon the rulers and the kings, "The meaning of all of this chapter is that it
refers to a
tyrant and an evil ruler. However, as for the just and noble one amongst them, then
entering upon him and seeing him and
helping him upon doing good is one of the most excellent
actions of good. Do you not see that 'Umar ibn Abdul-'Azeez used
to have as his companions the
best of the scholars at the time, such as 'Urwah ibn az-Zubair and his level, and Ibn Shihaab
az-Zuhree) and his level? Ibn Shihaab used to enter upon the ruler 'Abdul-Malik and his sons after
him as well
and from them who used to enter upon the rulers as well were ash-Sha'bee, Qabeesah,
Ibn Dhu'ayb and Raj'aa ibn Haywat
al-Kindee and Abul-Miqdaam - and he was a noble scholar -
al-Hasan al-Basree, Abuz Zinaad, Maalik ibn Anas, al-Awzaa'ee,
ash-Shaafi'ee and a whole group of
others who would b too many to mention. So if the scholar enters upon the ruler now
when there is a need for that and he says something good and he speaks with his knowledge, then
good. This is a matter wherein lies the Peasure of Allaah until the Day when he meets Him.
However, there being gatherings
that are a trial is more usually the case, and remaining
safe is by keeping away from that."
I say: he has spoken
truly and well and given sincere advice, may Allaah have mercy upon him.
Since they were like naked warners who do not
lie to their people. How could they not be like that
when they had heard the saying of Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu
alayhi wa sallam), "Whoever comes to
the ruler is put to trial." 26 And it is befitting that the people of knowledge be
like Aboo Haazim,
because 'Abdur-Rahmaan ibn Khaalid sent him a message and said, "Come to us so that we can ask
questions and you can narrate to us." So Aboo Haazim said, "Allaah's refuge is sought from
that. I met the people of knowledge
and they did not carry the Religion to the people of the world,
and I will not be the first to do that. So if you have
any need, then send news of it to us." So
'Abdur-Rahmaan went out to him and met him and he said to him, "You have increased
over us."27 Yoosuf ibn Asbaat said, "I heard Sufyaan ath-Thawree say, `If you see a reciter resorting
the door of a ruler then know that he is a thief. And if you see him resorting to the rich people
then know he is one
who does things for show.'"28
26 Reported by Aboo Daawood (no. 2859), at-Tirmidhee (no. 2256), an-Nasaa'ee (7/195~96),
Ahmad (1/357) and others, by
way of Sufyaan: from Aboo Moosaa: from Wahb ibn Munnabih: from Ibn 'Abbaas. Its chain of
narration is weak due to the
fact that Aboo Moosaa is unknown (majhool). However it has another chain reported by, al-Bayhaqee
(3/2/248) that strengthens it, if Allaah so wills. It also has two narrations that witness to its correctness
and I have brought
and referenced them in my treatise, Ar-Riyaa, Dhammuhu wa Atharuhus-Sayyi Fil-Ummah, (p. 34). So through
them it is
authentic and all praise is for Allaah at the beginning and the end.
27 Reported in Hilyatul-Awliyaa, (3/238).
28 Ibid. (6/387).
THE SCHOLAR SHOULD RECTIFY
In the saying of 'Umar (radiyallaahu 'anhu) describing
Jibreel (alaihis-salaam) there occurs, " .. his clothes
were very white and his hair was very black. No trace of journeying
could be seen upon him ..." this contains
a proof that in his gatherings and when he is narrating hadeeth, it is befitting
that the scholar and
the teacher should be in his best and most complete appearance and should have his best
He should take care and prepare himself for this by putting himself in order in such a
manner as will adorn him in front
of those present, those who agree with him and those who
disagree with him.
Likewise the Believer
loves that his garment should be clean and his shoes should be fine. So from
'Abdullaah ibn Mas'ood (radiyallaahu 'anhu)
from the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) who said,
"Nobody will enter Paradise who has in his heart a mustard seed
of pride." So a man said, "But a man
likes that his clothing should be good and his shoes should be fine." So the Prophet
wa sallam) said, "Indeed Allaah is beautiful and loves that which is beautiful. Pride is haughty
of the truth and having contempt for the people."
So it is recommenced for him that he should wear white clothing
as was the clothing of Jibreel
(alaihis-salaam) when the Companions saw him and likewise Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu
sallam) said, "Wear from your garments those that are white, because they are from the best of your
and shroud your dead in them."
However, he should avoid wearing the very finest of clothes, for fear of fame and
amongst the people and for fear of drawing the people's attention towards him. This is from
just as Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said, "Whoever abandoned fine
clothing out of humility to Allaah
and he is able to wear it, then Allaah will call him on the Day of
Resurrection at the head of all the people until He
gives him the choice to wear whichever garments of
the people of Eemaan he wants."
Taking Care of One's Hair
It is upon him also that he should tale care of his hair and put right any hair that is disorderly. He
and perfume it due to the saying of Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam),
"Whoever has hair, then let him
take care of it."
And if he has any grey hairs, he should change them with dye, in order to be contrary to the
and the Christians, and what is recommended is that he dyes with henna and with `katam' (a
plant which gives
a dark red, blackish dye). From Aboo Hurairah that Allaah's Messenger
(sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said, "The Jews and
the Christians do not dye, so act contrary to
29 Reported by Muslim, no. 91 and 148
30 Reported by Aboo Daawood (nos.
3878 and 4061), at-Tirmidhee (no. 994), Ibn Majaah (nos. 1472 and 3561) and others,
from the hadeeth of Ibn 'Abbaas (radiyallaahu
'anhu). The hadeeth is declared authentic by at-Tirmidhee and al-Haakim, adh-Dhahabee
agreed and Shaykh al-Albanee agreed.
At-Tirmidhee commented upon this hadeeth saying, "... and this is what
the people of knowledge love."
31 It is authentic
due to its different chains as I have made clear in my book, At-Tawaadu' fee daw'il-Kitaab was-Sunnatis-Saheehah,
32 Reported by Aboo Daawood (no. 4163) and others from the hadeeth of Aboo Hurairah (radiyallaahu 'anhu). Declared
authentic by our Shaykh Al-Albanee in As-Saheehah, (no. 500).
33 Ash-Shawkaanee (may Allaah have mercy on
him) said in Nailul-Awtaar (1/148) commenting
upon this hadeeth, "This shows that the reason for the prescription of dyeing
the hair and changing
grey hairs is to be contrary to the Jews and the Christians. So this shows that the recommendation
is something emphasized. Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) used to very greatly differ
from the People
of the Book and he used to command that. And this is a Sunnah which the salaf
have given great importance to. Therefore
you will see the people of history in
biographies will very often say, `... and he used to dye his hair or he had not
used to dye
lbn al-Jawziyy said, "A group from the Companions and the Taabi'een used to apply dye and Ahmad
ibn Hanbal when he had seen a man who had dyed his beard said, `I can see a man who has
revived something that has
died from the Sunnah,' and he hecarne very happy when he saw the
man who had dyed his beard. But it is upon him that in
dyeing, he should avoid using black
dye. From Jaabir ibn 'Abdullaah (radiyallaahu 'anhu) who said, "Aboo Quhaafah was
brought on the
day of the conquest of Makkah and his hair and his beard were extremely white like the
(a white plant ). So Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said, `Change this
with something and avoid black."
It is also upon him that he should avoid any foods whose smell is disliked, such as garlic, onions,
leeks and particularly smoking-which is an affliction that has befallen many of the people. So the
gatherings of knowledge
are attended and surrounded by the Angels and they are harmed by the
things that cause harm to the children of Aadam.
In a narration of the same hadeeth (of Jibreel)
reported by an-Nasaa'ee there occurs the wording, "There came a man who
was the best of the
people in the appearance of his face and he was the best smelling of the people. It was as if his
clothes had never been touched by dirt."
So in summary, it is upon that person that he should keep up upon the characteristics
of the fitrah,
(the sunnah followed by the Prophets). From 'Aa'ishah(radiyallaahu 'anha), who said, "Allaah's
(sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said, `Ten things are from the fitrah. Clipping the moustache,
leaving the beard, using
the siwaak (tooth-stick), cleaning out the nose with water, clipping the
nails, washing the parts between the fingers,
plucking the hair from the armpits, shaving the private
parts and using water.'" Zakkariyya 36 said, "Mus'ab 37 said,
`I have forgotten the tenth one unless it
was taking water in the mouth while making wudoo.'" And Qutaybah 38 said, "Wakee
39 said, `Usage
of water means using it to clean oneself after using the toilet'"40
33 Reported by al-Bukhaaree (10/354,
AL-Fath) and Muslim (no. 2103).
34 A white plant having white flowers and fruits.
35 Reported by Muslim (no. 2102).
36 He is Ibn Abee Zaa'idah, one of the narrators in the chain of narration.
37 He is Ibn Shaibah, the next narrator
in the chain.
38 He is Ibn Saeed, one of the Shaikhs who narrated the hadeeth to Muslim.
39 He is Ibn al-Jarrah ibn
Maleeh, the narrator from Zakariyya.
40 Reported by Muslim (no. 261).
HONOURING AND RESPECTING
GATHERINGS OF KNOWLEDGE
In the saying of 'Umar ibn al-Khattaab (radiyallaahu
'anhu) there occurs "... until Jibreel came to the
Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) , and he put his two knees against
his two knees and he placed his hands
upon his thighs."
41 (In this) there is a proof for the obligation of respecting
the gatherings of
knowledge and for sitting in front of and with the people of knowledge, in a way showing manners
There occurs in the hadeeth of Aboo Dharr and Aboo Hurairah (may Allaah be pleased with them both) in
narration of an-Nasaa'ee, that they both said, "Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) used
to sit along with
his Companions and a stranger would come and not know which one was him, and
would not know which one to ask. Therefore,
we sought from Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa
sallam) that we should be allowed to make him a special sitting
place, so that the stranger would
know him when he came to him. So we built for him a small seat made of clay and he used
upon it. We were sitting around and Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) was in his sitting
when a man came, who was the best of the people in face and he smelt the best of all the
people and his clothes were such
that it was as if no dirt had touched them. So he gave salaam at
the edge of the carpet, saying, `As-salaamu alaika, O
Muhammad.' So he responded and replied to
his salaam and then Jibreel said, `Shall I come near, O Muhammad?' He said,
"Draw near," and so he
continued saying, `Shall I draw near?' and he was saying to him, "Come near," to the point that
placed his hands upon the two knees of Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam)"
The Respect that the Companions
used to Give to Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa
When the Companions (radiyallaahu 'anhum) sat with
the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam), they would
be still and silent as if they had birds on their heads. From Aboo
Sa'eed al-Khudree (radiyallaahu
'anhu) , "That Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) stood upon the minbar
and said, `What I fear
for you after me is just that the blessings of the earth will be opened up for you,' and then he
mentioned the worldly pleasures, he mentioned the first and continued with the second. Then a man
stood up and said,
`O Messenger of Allaah, will good produce evil?' So the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa
sallam) remained silent and we said,
`He is receiving Revelation.' The people remained silent as if
they had birds upon their heads."42
said, "Their saying, `The people whilst sitting with this person were as though they
had birds upon their heads,' has
two meanings. One meaning of it is that the people were so still
and were not moving at all, and they were lowering their
gaze, because a bird only settles on
something that is very still. So if a person is calm and composed, it is said about
him, `He is as still
as if he had a bird upon his head.'
The second saying is that (Prophet) Sulaymaan the son of
Daawood (alaihis-salaam) used to say to
the wind, `Blow upon us,' and he used to say to the birds, `Give us shade.' So
the wind would blow
calmly upon him and his companions and the birds would shade them. His companions in his
would keep their eyes down out of respect and out of awe before Sulaymaan
(alaihis-salaam). They would be still and not
move, and would not speak with anything unless he
41 This is a sitting, which resembles the manner of sitting in the tashahhud
for the Prayer. This was the practice of the
students of knowledge to the point that they came to be known as `The People
of the Companions of the Knees,' and this is
how they used to sit in the gatherings of knowledge.
42 Reported by al-Bukhaaree,
(Eng. trans. vol. 4, no. 95).
asked them question, whereupon they would respond to him.
So therefore it is said about a people
when they are still and quiet, `They are dignified scholars as if they have birds
over their heads,'
meaning they resemble the companions of Sulaymaan (alaihis-salaam)."43
Some of the Companions (radiyallaahu
'anhum) would not look at the face of Allaah's Messenger
(sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) but would just take a glance at
him, and this was due to their respect for
him. They used to lower their gaze when they sat in his presence to the point
that if one of them
wanted to describe his appearance they would not have been able to describe him. 'Abdur-Rahmaan
Shumasaasah al-Mihree said, "We were present along with 'Amr ibn al-Aas and he was at the
point of death. He was weeping
for a long time, he turned his face towards the wall and his son
started saying to him, `O my father, did not Allaah's
Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) give you
the good news of such and such?'
See he turned with this face and
he said, `The best thing that we can count upon is the testification
that, `None has the right to be worshipped except
Allaah and Muhammad is the Messenger of
Allaah.' As for me, then I went through three phases. I witnessed myself and nobody
Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) more than I did and there was nothing more beloved to me than
I should be able to get hold of him and kill him. So if I would have died upon that state I would
have been from the people
of the Fire. Then Allaah placed Islaam in my heart, so I came to the
Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) and I said,
`Stretch out your right hand so that I may give you
pledge of allegiance.' He stretched out his right hand (but) I withdrew
So he said, `What is wrong with you, O 'Amr?' I said, `I wanted to make a condition.' He said, `To
condition?' I said, `That I should be forgiven.' So the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam)
said, `Do you not know that
Islaam wipes away whatever came before it and that migration wipes away
whatever came before it, and that Hajj wipes away
whatever came before it?" Then 'Amr ibn al-Aas
said, `And there was nobody more beloved to me than Allaah's Messenger
wa sallam), nor greater in my eyes than him, but I was not able to look straight at him, out
respect for him. If I was asked to describe him, I wouldn't be able, because I had not
looked straight at him. If I had
died in that state I would have hoped that I should be from the
people of Paradise. Then we took charge of affairs and
I don't know what my state is from these
affairs. So if I die, then let no wailing woman accompany me nor any fire, and
when you bury me
then scatter the earth upon me and then remain around my grave for such a time as you would be
to sacrifice some camels and distribute their meat, in order that I should take comfort from
your presence and that I
may see what answer I give to the messengers of my Lord."44
How the Taabi'een gave respect to the Scholars and their Gatherings
The Taabi'een and those after them followed this same way. Mugheerah said, "We used to have awe
of Ibraaheem just
as the people would have awe of their ruler."45 Ayyoob said, "A man used to sit
with al-Hasan for three years but not
ask him anything out of respect and awe of him."
'Abdur-Rahmaan Ibn Hurmulah al-Aslamee said, "No person would be bold
enough to ask any
question of Sa'eed ibn al-Musayyib until he asked permission from him." Ibnul-Khayyaat said in
of Maalik ibn Anas, "Answers would be left and he would not be asked again out of awe and
the people asking questions
would lower the heads with their chins hanging down. He manifested
the light of nobility and the honour of a king in piety.
He was one held in awe even hough he was
not a ruler."
Aboo 'Aasim said, "We were in the presence of Ibn 'Awn and
he was narrating hadeeth. So
Ibraaheem ibn 'Abdur-Rahmaan ibn al-Hasan passed by with a mounted escort. And he was at
time acclaimed as being a ruler after his brother Muhammad had been killed, but nobody dared to
even look at
him, not to mention getting up, out of respect and awe for Ibn Awn."46
43 Al-Khateeb in Al-Jaami' li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee
wa Aadaabaais Saami', (1/192~193).
44 Reported by Muslim, (no. 121).
45 And Ibraaheem was Ibraaheem ibn Yazeed ibn
46 He was 'Abdullaah ibn Awn ibn Artaat al-Basree.
This was due to the fact that knowledge in their understanding
was something practical, and
something which changed the manners of a person and led him towards good. Knowledge was not
just a case, with them, of gathering facts in order to compete with the foolish people, to debate with
to show off in front of the common people and to attain the head of gatherings.
Al-Hasan said, "It used to be the case
that a man would seek knowledge and would not remain for
long before its effect would be seen in his humility, in his
manners, upon his tongue and in his sight
and in his hand."47
It is befitting that the scholars cause their students
to honour the gatherings of knowledge and
cause them to have respect in the souls of their students. That they direct
them and put them right
if they make any mistake.
Ahmad ibn Sulaymaan al-Qattaan said, "It used to be the case with
'Abdur-Rahmaan ibn Mahdee
that nobody would speak in his gathering, nor would anyone sharpen a pen, nor would anyone
If anyone spoke or sharpened a pen he would shout, put on his shoes and go to his house.
Likewise with Ibn Numayr-and
he was one of the strictest of the people in this. He would become
angry and shout, and if he saw anyone sharpening a
pen his face would alter. Also the people in the
gathering of Wakee' would sit as if they were in prayer, and if he saw
them doing anything he
disliked he would put on his shoes and enter his house."48
Correct Behavior of the Students
I am very surprised at youths who, when they sit in a gathering of knowledge, you see them
troubling the scholar in
his gathering and competing with him. When the scholar is asked a question
he seeks to precede him with the answer, and
if the scholar's answer does not please him you find
him winking at his associates.
Aboo 'Aasim an-Nabeel said, "I
witnessed Sufyaan ath-Thawree and a youth from the people of
knowledge was present at his gathering, and he was behaving
as if he were the head of the
gathering, speaking out, showing his importance by the knowledge over those: older than
Sufyaan became angry and said, `The Salaf were not like this. One of them had not used to claim
nor would he sit at the head of a gathering until he had sought this knowledge for thirty
years. But you give yourself
importance over those older than you. Get up and leave me, and I do
not want to see you near my gathering." He said, "And
I heard Sufyaan ath-Thawree say, `If you
see a youth speaking out in the presence of the Shaikhs, even if he has reached
a level of
knowledge, then despair of his being good, because he has little shame."49
I say: Sufyaan spoke truly and
well, for the Salaf were upon a high level of manners. It is reported
from Ibn 'Umar (may Allaah be pleased with them
both) that he said, "Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi
wa sallam) said, `The example of the Believer is like that
of a green tree; its leaves do not fall, nor
wither away.' So the people began saying, `It is such and such tree.' Ibn
`Umar said, `So I wanted
to say that it was the date-palm tree, but I was a young youth and so felt ashamed (to speak).'
Allaah's Messenger said, `It is the date-palm.'"50 Al-Bayhaqee commented upon this hadeeth saying,
ibn 'Umar felt ashamed due to his young age, to speak out in the presence of the elders.
This was something praiseworthy
from him. 'Umar (radiyallaahu 'anhu) desired that his son should
speak out in order to show his knowledge, and the Prophet
(sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) had questioned
his Companions about that tree. So informing about it would not have been
bad manners, since he
asked them so that if they did not know he could inform them of it. And Allaah knows best."51
All these reports are from Al-Jaami' li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadaabaais Saami', (1/184~185) and Jaami Bayaan al-Ilm,
48 Al-Jaami' li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadaabaais Saami', (1/193)
49 Reported by al-Bayhaqee in Al-Madkhal ilas-Sunanil-Kubraa',
50 Reported by al-Bukhaaree (Eng. trans. vol. 1, nos. 58 and 59) and Mustim (no. 2811).
51 Al-Madkhal ilas-Sunanil-Kubraa',
Then you see one of them sitting with one leg resting
upon the other, and he might even have his
feet pointing towards the scholar. If you were to ask him about something he
could only manage
laughter. So it is fitting that the saying of Aboo Zayd ad-Daboosee 52 be quoted in his regard:
is it that when I overcome him with a proof
He meets me with laughter?
If laughter were a sign of
a person's knowledge-
Then none would be more knowledgeable than that
beast of the desert."
Or the saying of Sufyaan
ibn 'Uyainah, "'Ubaydullaah ibn 'Umar came to us in Koofah a long time
ago. When he saw the students of knowledge and
how badly the knowledge was being treated he
said, `You have disgraced the knowledge and its people. If 'Umar had reached
me and you he would
have given us a painful beating.'"53
And how fine is the saying of al-Layth ibn Sa'd, who one
day saw something reprehensible from the
students of hadeeth and said, "You have a greater need for a small amount of
good manners than
you do for a great deal of knowledge."54
However it is fitting that correction is done in a way
that will make the affair easy and not cause
difficulties, and will cause them to be cheerful and not repel them. Since
gentleness is never applied
to anything except that it adorns it, and it is not plucked away from anything except that
rendered ugly, and Allaah loves gentleness in all affairs.
Educating by Example
It is upon the scholar and
teacher that he avoids joking with the people of his gathering in the
gathering, since this removes the sense of reverence
and causes respect to depart. Because if he
jokes with one who is noble he will resent him for that, and if he jokes with
a lowly person it will
cause him to become bold and forward with him. Joking eats up respect just as fire consumes dry
Mis'ar ibn Kidaam al-Hilaalee said as advice to his son:55
"I have granted you, O Kidaam, my sincere
So listen to the saying of a father who sincerely
wishes well for you.
As for joking and arguing-then leave both
They are two traits that I am not pleased with
for a close-friend,
I have tried them both and not found
To be a good companion for a neighbour or a
And stupidity will only cause a young man to be
amongst his people,
And it will not matter to them how fine his
Furthermore the wise scholars of
this ummah used to teach fine character and good manners to
their students. Al-Hasan ibn Ismaa'eel said, "I heard my father
say, `In the gathering of Ahmad
52 Al-Fawaa'idul-Bahiyyah fee taraajimil-Hanafiyyah, (p. 109).
53 Al-Jaami' li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee
wa Aadaabaais-Saami', (1/405).
54 Al-Jaami' li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadaabaais-Saami', (1/405).
around five thousand people or more would gather. Less
than five hundred would write narrations,
and the rest would be learning good manners and correct behaviour from him."56
56 Manaaqibul-Imaam Ahmad ibn Hanbal of Ibn al-Jawzee, (p. 210).
ASKING QUESTIONS IS THE
KEY TO KNOWLEDGE
The fact that Jibreel (alaihis-salaam) asked questions
to Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam)
about Islaam, eemaan and ihsaan, the Last Hour and its signs, contains
proof that asking questions
is the key to knowledge and this is stated in the Mighty Book:
Ask the people of the Reminder,
if you do not know. Soorah an-Nahl (16):43 and
Soorah al-Anbiyaa (21):7.
Also Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi
wa sallam) stated that it is a cure for ignorance, as occurs in
the hadeeth of the man who had the head fracture, where
he said, "Why didn't they ask when they
were ignorant? Indeed the cure for not knowing is to ask."
the matter is as I have explained, then asking questions in a good way will assist in that
matter, because whoever asks
a question in a good way will learn. Therefore the great scholar, Ibn
Qayyim al-Jawziyyah (may Allaah have mercy on him)
said in Miftaah Daaris-Sa'aadah, "And knowledge
has six levels. The first of them is asking questions in a good manner
... there are some people who
are prevented from it (knowledge) because they do not ask questions in a good manner, either
because they never ask questions, or because they ask a question about something when something
else is more important
than it. Like the person who asks about superfluous things ignorance of
which will not harm him, but leaves those things
which are essential for him to know. This is the
condition of many of the foolish students."
Mujaahid said, "Knowledge
will not be learnt by one who is too shy, nor one who is too proud."58 Al-Khateeb
al-Baghdaadee said in his book, Al-Faqeeh
wal-Mutafaqqih (2/143), "And it is befitting that
shyness should not prevent a person from asking questions about something
that has happened to
him. But if he does become too shy and embarrassed to ask a question to the scholar, then he
give his question to one he feels at home with or one he feels relaxed with for him to ask the
scholar on his behalf and
to inform him about its ruling."
So in summary, whoever wishes to reach the levels of the scholars let him begin by asking
questions. How fine is the saying Allaah has caused the scholar Ibn al'Arabee 59 to say, "How close
the things are
to being attained when they are given their due worth, and how far from attainment
when they are not given their due worth.
So ask the scholar you will be a scholar like him.
Whoever attains wide knowledge must spend the dowry for that. So carefully
knowledge which you give a ruling with, there is no good in knowledge without careful consideration.
a person may strive and still be falling short, and the efforts of a person may be frustrated,
even, though he doesn't
fall short. The men whose actions we take as an example have gone and
those men who censure every evil action also. I
am left within the later people who seek to adorn
one another to hide each others short-comings."
Know that asking
questions in a good manner will help the scholar to give the answer, as Maymoon
ibn Mihraan said, "Asking questions in
a good manner is half of knowledge."60 Therefore it is
57 Saheeh, as I have explained in my abridgement of Miftaah Daaris-Sa'aadah,
58 Reported by ad-Daarimee (1/138), al-Bayhaqee in his Madkhal ilas-Sunan (no. 410) and al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee
wal-Mutafaqqih, (2/ 144).
59 i.e., Aboo Bakr Muhammad ibn 'Abdullaah al-Maalikee (d. 543H).
by al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee in Al-Jaami' li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadaabaais Saami', (1/213).
essential to explain the knowledge of how to ask questions,
because being ignorant of that will lead
to confusion. Maalik ibn Anas said, "Ibn 'Ajlaan came to Zayd ibn Aslam to ask
him about something
but he became confused in it, so Zayd said to him, `Go away and learn how to ask questions and
come and ask. '"61
(i) The question should be a question to find something out, it should not be asked to
nor should it be to show someone's ignorance, and it should not be made
as a test for someone. Because this is the condition
mentioned in the Book of Allaah:
Ask the people of the Reminder, if you do not know. Soorah an-Nahl (16):43 and
So one who does not know then he asks in order that he may be taught. However, it is permissible
one who knows that he asks the scholar in order to teach those people who are sitting round
about. Because this is what
Jibreel (alaihis-salaam) did with Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa
sallam), his questions were asked in order
to teach the Companions (radiyallaahu 'anhum) who were
sitting around the Prophet.
(ii) It is not allowed to ask questions
about something which there is no need of, things
whose answers will trouble the one who is asking the. question. Anas
(radiyallaahu 'anhu) said,
"Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) gave a khutbah and I have never heard the
like of it.
He (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said, `If you knew what I know, then you would certainly laugh only a
and you would weep a lot."' So the Companions (radiyallaahu 'anhum) covered up their faces and
they were weeping, so a
man said, `Who is my father?' He said, `Your father is so and so.' So this
aayah was sent down:
Do not ask about things,
which, if they are made plain to you may cause
trouble to you.
(iii) Likewise, it is not allowed to ask questions
about things which may cause difficulty
and cause hardship to the questioner or for other Muslims. Sa'd (radiyallaahu
'anhu) said that
the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said, "The severest of the Muslims in sin with regard to the
Muslims is one who asks about something that was not forbidden but it is made forbidden due to his
asking the question."
(iv) Therefore the Companions (radiyallaahu 'anhum) and the Taabi'een used to hate asking
questions about things
before they happened and they would not answer those questions.
Since this is going to excess which is something Allaah
has forbidden and He has declared His
Prophet free from it. He ordered His Prophet to say:
Say, `I do not ask you
for any reward for it and I am not one of the ones
who goes beyond bounds.' Soorah Saad (38):86.
Ar-Rabee' ibn Khuthaim
said, "O servant of Allaah, whatever knowledge Allaah has given to you in
His Book, then give praise and give thanks to
Allaah for that. Whatever knowledge He has kept
concealed from you, then leave it to the One who knows it and don't go
to excesses, because Allaah,
the Mighty and Majestic said to His Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam):
I do not ask
you for any reward for it and I am not one of the ones who
goes to excesses. It is just a reminder for all of men and
jinn. And you will
certainly know the news of its truth after a short while (after death and the
62 Sooraah al-Maa'idah (5):101. Reported by al-Bukhaaree, (Eng. trans. vol. 6, nos. 145
and 146) and Muslim, (no. 2359).
63 Reported by al-Bukhaaree, (Eng. trans. vol. 9, nos. 392) and Muslim, (no. 2358).
Ibn 'Abdul-Barr said in his book, Jaami' Bayaanil-'Ilm
wa Fadlih,i (2/138~139) "A group of the
people of knowledge said, `The opinion (Ra'y) that is blameworthy, criticised,
abandoned and which
it is not allowed to look into, nor to occupy oneself with, is innovated opinion and its like from
But others say, and they are the majority of the people of knowledge, `Blameworthy opinion that
mentioned in these narrations by the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) and from the Companions
and the Taabi'een
is speaking about the rulings of the sharee'ah based upon personal opinion of
what is good, and based upon surmise, preoccupying
oneself with intricate and difficult matters, and
with thorny questions, referring details of happenings to each other
and making analogy based upon
that without referring them back to their origins and looking at their causes and taking
consideration. Applying one's opinion before things actually occur and then laying down details to
on from this and resultant side issues before anything happens and speaking about this
before these things occur. This
is like pure speculation. They say: so preoccupying oneself and
delving into these things is an abandonment of what occurs
in the Sunnah. It involves looking into
things which the Sunnah is silent about, and it means abandonment of occupying
oneself with that
which is essential from the Sunnah and the Book of Allaah, the Mighty and Majestic, and its
I say: and even if the excuse given for this hair-splitting, this laying down of details, this
giving hypothetical answers,
was that it is used just to train oneself upon the matters of fiqh, then it
is still the same as is pointed out by Haafiz
ibn Hajr al-Asqalaanee (may Allaah have mercy on him) in his
book, Fath al-Baaree.64
(v) Al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee
(may Allaah have mercy on him) in his book, Jaami' li-Akhlaaqir-
Raawee wa Adaabis-Saami', (1/211~214) brings a number
of chapters in this
regard and we will mention the most important of these headings due to their importance:
correct manners is that when the scholar of hadeeth narrates a hadeeth and then something
appears to the student while
he is narrating and he wants to ask about that thing, he should not ask
about it at that time. Rather he should have patience
until the narrator has finished narrating his
hadeeth and then he can ask about whatever he wants to ask about.
should avoid asking the narrator of hadeeth when his heart is preoccupied. It is not befitting that
he should ask him
when he is standing up, nor when he is walking, because there is a saying
appropriate to each place, and there are places
appropriate for the narrating of Hadeeth-and they
exclude the streets and lowly places.
It is obligatory that the
questioner should mention to the scholar of hadeeth those chains of the
hadeeth which he wants to hear narrated from him,
and if a hadeeth has many chains the
questioner should specify the best of them and should specify the points of benefit
he wishes to hear
narrated by him. If the scholar of hadeeth responds and grants his request to narrate to him, then
student should be easy upon him and he should not trouble him.
(vi) It is permissible to ask a scholar about his proof.
Al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee said in his
book, Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih, (2/149), "And if the scholar gives him an answer
to his question it
is permissible for him to ask him about his answer, did he say it based upon a narration or did he
say it based upon opinion."
(vii) It is hated to keep repeating a question to the scholar in a troublesome manner.
al-Baghdaadee said in his book, Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih, (2/149), "And if he asks the
scholar to explain
and he explains it to him and then he repeats again and asks him to explain
again, it is allowed for the scholar to add
more. If he asks him again after that then it is allowed for
the scholar to hold his tongue because frequent repetition
will vex him. However it is
recommendable for the scholar to be mild and treat with tolerance and make allowance for the
64 Vol. 8, p.282.
(viii) It is allowed for him to ask about speech that
is unclear to him. 'Abdullaah ibn
Mas'ood (radiyallaahu 'anhu) said, "I prayed along with Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu
alayhi wa sallam) one
night and he stood for a very long time until I thought about doing something bad." A student said
to him, "What did you think of doing?" He said, "I thought of sitting down and leaving him."65
65 Reported by al-Bukhaaree,
(Eng. trans. vol. 2, no. 236) and Muslim, (no. 773).
THE SAYING `I DO NOT
KNOW' IS HALF OF KNOWLEDGE
The saying of Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi
wa sallam), "The one who is asked the question does
not know better than the one who is asking," Which he said when Jibreel
(alaihis-salaam) asked him
about the Last Hour, is a proof that when a scholar is asked about anything which he does not
it is befitting that he should say, `I do not know.' Likewise the saying of 'Umar (radiyallaahu 'anhu) at
end of the hadeeth, "Allaah and His Messenger know best," which he said when Allaah's
Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa
sallam) asked him, "O 'Umar, do you know the one who was asking the
Whoever shows humility then his wisdom
will be raised
So this saying does not reduce the value of the scholar at all, rather it is from his piety and from his
Religion to do so. Because above every possessor of knowledge there is one who knows more and
the One who knows all.
So let the one who takes this stand, remember and keep in mind that this
saying is a part of the completion and perfection
of his Religion. Because even the Angels who are
drawn close did not feel shy from this part of the clear truth, when
the Lord of all creation said to
"(Inform Me of the names of these things if you are truthful)." The Angels
replied, `How Perfect and free from imperfections You are! We have no
knowledge except that which You have taught
to us. Indeed, You are the
All-Knowing and the All-Wise." Soorah al-Baqarah (2):32.
And ash-Sha'bee (may Allaah have
mercy on him), when he was asked a question about something said,
"I do not know." So it was said to him, "Don't you feel
shy to say I don't know and you are the
scholar of the people of `Iraaq?" So he said, "But the Angels didn't feel shy
when they said, `How
Perfect You are Our Lord, we have no knowledge except that which You have taught
one who knows his own level, should carefully consider the saying of Allaah, The Most
High to His Messenger (sallallahu
alayhi wa sallam)
Say, `I do not ask you for any reward for this and I am not one to invent
and add extra things."67
Soorah Saad (38):86.
'Abdullaah ibn Mas'ood (radiyallaahu 'anhu) said, "Whoever has some knowledge then let him speak,
and whoever does not have knowledge with him, then let him say, `Allaah knows best.' Because
Allaah said to His Prophet:
Say, `I do not ask you for any reward for this and I am not one to invent
and add extra things."
66 Reported by
Ibn 'Abdul-Barr in Jaami' Bayaanil-`Ilm, (2/51) and al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee in Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih,
Reported by ad-Daarimee, (1/62), Ibn 'Abdul-Barr in Jaami' Bayaanil-Ilm (2/51), al-Bayhaqee in Madkhal ilas-Sunan, (no.
and al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee in Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih, (2/171) by way of different chains from al-A'mash, ad-Duhaa
Masrooq with it. I say: It is saheeh.
This was the manner of the Pious Predecessors
found in numerous reports that pleasing behavior, pure manners, this character which is the
character of a person upon
the Sunnah-all this is found to be from the manners of the Salafus-Saalih:
the Companions, the Taabi'een and those who
followed them upon their good until the Day
Aboo Bakr as-Siddeeq (radiyallaahu 'anhu) was asked a
question about an aayah from the Book of
Allaah and he said in reply, "Which earth will support me? Which sky will shade
me? Where can I
go? What will I be able to do? If I say about an aayah from the Book of Allaah other than what
the Perfect and Most High, intended."68 The same saying is related from 'Aloe ibn Abee Taalib
It is also reported from him that he was asked about a matter so he said, "I have no knowledge
about it." Then he
said, "How pleasing this is for the liver, how pleasing this is for the liver, how
pleasing this is for the liver." So
the people said, "O Chief of the Believers! And what is that thing?"
He said, "That thing is that a man is asked about
something which he does not know, and he says,
`Allaah knows best. '"70
Ibn 'Umar was asked a question, "Does the
paternal aunt inherit?" He replied, "I don't know." So the
one who was asking the question said, "You-you don't know and
we don't know?!" So he said, "Yes.
Go to the people of knowledge in al-Madeenah and ask them." Then when the man left,
kissed his own hands and said, "How finely Aboo 'Abdur-Rahmaan has spoken. He was asked about
which he did not know, and he said, `I don't know. '"71
This was the way of the Companions (radiyallaahu 'anhum). Each
one of them would have loved that
somebody else besides him sufficed him and gave an answer in his place.
`ibn 'Aazib (radiyallaahu 'anhu) said, "I have seen three hundred from the people of Badr,
and there was not one of them
except that he loved that his companion would give a reply to
questions on his behalf."72
Then the Taabi'een reached
and inherited this practice. 'Abdur-Rahmaan ibn Abee Laylaa said, "I
met one hundred and twenty from the Ansaar from the
Companions of Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu
alayhi wa sallam). One of them would be asked a question and he would give
it to somebody else-until
it would come back to the one who had been asked in the first place."73 Al-Qaasim ibn Muhammad
was asked a question so he said, "I do not know." Then he said, "By Allaah, that a man should live
in ignorance after
having known the right of Allaah upon him is better than that he should say
something which he does not know. " 74
same behaviour influenced the successors of the Taabi'een (radiyallaahu 'anhu) and one of the
most successful of them
upon that was the Imaam of the place of Hijrah, Imaam Maalik (may Allaah
have mercy on him). So it is reported from Ibn
Wahb who said, "I heard Maalik and the saying of al-Qaasim,
`That a man should live in ignorance is better for him than
that he should speak about
Allaah that which he does not know," was quoted to him. So Maalik said, "This is speech which
68 Reported by Ibn 'Abdul-Barr in Jaami' Bayaanil-Ilm (2/52) and al-Bayhaqee in Madkhal ilas-Sunan, (no. 792). It
established from him through a number of chains of narration. Ibn 'Abdul-Barr said, "The like of it is reported
Bakr, Maymoon ibn Mihraan, 'Aamir ash-Sha'bee and Ibn Abee Mulaykah."
69 Jaami' Bayaanil-'Ilm wa Fadlihi,
70 Reported by ad-Daarimee, (1/62463), al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee in Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih, (2/171) and al-Bayhaqee
Madkhal ilas-Sunan, (no. 794). through various chains of narration from him.
71 Reported by ad-Daarimee, (1/63),
Ibn 'Abdul-Barr in Jaami' Bayaanil-Ilm wa Fadlihi (2/52), al-Khateeb in Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih,
(2/171~172) and al-Bayhaqee
in Madkhal ilas-Sunan, (no. 796).
72 Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih, (2/165).
73 Reported by ad-Daarimee, (1/53), Ibn Sa'ad
in At-Tabaqat (6/110) and others. I say: Its chain of narration is authentic.
74 Reported by ad-Daarimee (1/48), Aboo
Khaythamah in Al-'Ilm (no.90), Ibn 'Abdul-Barr in Jaami Bayaanil-'Ilm (2/53), al-Fasawee
in Al-Ma'rifah wat-Taareekh (1/546
& 547) and al-Khateeb in Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih (2/173).
be accepted." Then Maalik mentioned Aboo Bakr as-Siddeeq
(radiyallaahu 'anhu), and he mentioned
the excellence that Allaah particularized Aboo Bakr with, then Maalik said, "But
(radiyallaahu 'anhu) said in that time, `I do not know.' Then why should I not say, `I do not know. '"75
ibn Mahdee said, "A man came to Maalik ibn Anas to ask him a question about
something. For a number of days he would not
give him any answer, so then he said, `O Aboo
'Abdullaah! I want to leave now and I have repeatedly come to you.' So he
held his head down for a
long time ... then he raised it up, and said, `It is just as Allaah has willed. O person! I only
about that which I hold to be good, and I am not able to answer this question of yours.'"76 Ibn Wahb
I used to hear him frequently say, `I do not know.' If we were to write down how often
he said, `I do not know,' we would
have filled many sheets."77
This practice, this behaviour and this rightly-guided way became the practice of the wise
such as ash-Sha'bee, Ibraaheem an-Nakha'ee, Sa'eed ibn Jubayr, Muhammad ibn 'Ajlaan, 'Abdullaah
Ibn Hurmuz, Ayyoob as-Sakhtiyaanee, 'Amr ibn Deenaar and others (may Allaah have mercy
on him). To such an extent that
it would be difficult in a place like this to mention all their names, to
the point that the composer of the poem said:
So if you don't know that which you are asked about,
And you do not have knowledge about it,
Then do not speak
about it without understanding,
Because error is something that bites at the people of knowledge;
And if you are rendered
unable by an affair, then say,
`I have no report about that which you ask me.'
So this with the scholars is half of
This is what the wise people have always said and continue to say.
Some matters that will assist in this
In attainment of this affair, they were helped by certain matters:
(i) The fact that they used to flee away
from giving rulings and they had not used to hurry
to give rulings. One of them used to have an overwhelming desire that
his brother would
be able to help out and answer the question in his place. This has preceded in the report from
ibn 'Aazib (radiyallaahu 'anhu) and the other report from 'Abdur Rahmaan ibn Abee Laylaa.
(ii) They would not give religious
rulings about those things they were able to leave off
giving a ruling about, matters for which there was no text, for
fear of falling into sin.
Because whoever gives a Religious ruling without certainty of it and without knowledge,
the sin of it will fall upon the one who gave that verdict. 'Uqbah ibn Muslim said, "I
accompanied Ibn 'Umar for thirty
months and very often he would be asked a question and he would
say, `I don't know.' Then he would turn aside and say,
`Do you know what these people want? They
want to mike our backs a bridge leading to Hellfire. '"78
(iii) The desire
of each of them would be just to be saved with Allaah. Maalik ibn Anas (may
Allaah have mercy on him) said, "Rabee'ah
narrated to me saying, `Ibn Khaldah said, `O Rabee'ah! I
see that you give verdicts to the people. So if a man comes to
you, asking you about something,
then don't let your desire be to extract him from that which he has fallen into, but
let your desire be
to free yourself from that which he is asking you about. ''"79
75 Reported by al-Fasawee in Al-Ma'rifah
wat-Taareekh, (1/546) and al-Bayhaqee in Madkhal ilas-Sunan, (no. 808).
76 Reported by Abu Nu'aym in Al-Hilyah, (6/323)
77 Jaami' Bayaanil'Ilm, (2/54).
78 Reported in Jaami' Bayaanil-'Ilm wa-Fadlihi, (2/54).
by al-Fasawee in Al-Ma'rifah wat-Tareekh, (1/556) and al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee in Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih
iv) The fact that whoever abandons saying, `I do not know,'
then he has been mortally
wounded. Ibn 'Abbaas (radiyallaahu 'anhu) said, "When a scholar leaves aside the saying, `I
know,' then he has been mortally wounded."80
(v) They learned that the saying, `I do not know,' is half of
knowledge. Ash-Sha'bee said,
`I do not know,' is half of knowledge."81 The same wording is reported from Abud-Dardaa.82
Likewise whoever seeks knowledge of that which he does not know then it will reach him, and
whoever claims to have
knowledge of that which he does not really know then the examination will
reveal his true value, "and whoever claims that
which he does not have, then the witnesses of the
examination will prove him a liar, and he will run in knowledge like
the last horse in a race, the one
left behind by the fast horses on the day of the wager."
said, "Learn the saying, `I do not know,' and do not learn the saying, `I
know.' Because if you say, `I do not know,'
then they will teach you until you do know, but if you
keep saying `I do know,' then they will ask you until you do not
know."83 Whoever does this is
rightly guided and upon the way of salvation, as Maalik ibn Anas (may Allaah have mercy
on him) said,
"It is fitting that the scholar becomes accustomed with regard to matters which are a problem for
that he says, `I do not know.' And then hopefully good will be made ready for him."84
This is what they used to teach
Since the affair of the Salafus-Saalih (may Allaah have mercy on them) was firmly settled upon that, this
noble quality became a manner which the teacher would teach to his students and train them upon.
Maalik ibn Anas (may
Allaah have mercy on him) heard 'Abdullaah ibn Yazeed ibn Hurmuz say, "It is
fitting that the scholar narrates to those
who sit with him the saying, `I do not know.' Until that
becomes a fundamental principle for them, in front of them, which
they can flee to when one of
them is asked about something which he doesn't know; so that he will be able to say, `I do
In conclusion, whoever thinks that he has no need of learning ... then he is at the edge of a cliff
has a very long drop.
80 Reported by ibn 'Abdul-Barr in Jaami' Bayaanil-'Ilm wa-Fadlihi (2/54), al-Khateeb in Al-Faqeeh
wal-Mutafaqqih (2/172), al-Bayhaqee
in Madkhal ilas-Sunan, (no.813) by way of Maalik, from Ibn 'Ajlaan, from him with
it. I say: Its chain of narration is
81 Reported by ad-Daarimee (1/63), al-Khateeb in Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih
(2/173) and al-Bayhaqee in Madkhal ilas-Sunan,
(no.810). Through chains of narration from Aboo 'Awaanah, from al-Mugheerah,
from him with it. I say: And it is authentic.
82 Jaami' Bayaanil-'Ilm wa Fadlihi (2/54).
83 Ibid., (2/55).
Mentioned by Ibn 'Abdul-Barr in Jaami' Bayaanil-ILm wa Fadlihi (2/53~54), quoting from Ibn Wahb in his book Al-Majaalis,
it is reported by al-Bayhaqee in Al-MadhkhaL ilas-Sunan (no. 808) by way of Ibn Wahb.
ADVICE FOR THE CARE OF
THE STUDENTS OF KNOWLEDGE
The saying of the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam),
"O 'Umar, do you know the one who asked the
questions?" contains the manner of the scholar's drawing the attention of
his students and of elders
besides them to beneficial points of knowledge, and to striking points of things that happen,
to benefit them and to keep them alert.85
Small plants in the Gardens of the Scholars
The students are
like small plants that grow up in the gardens of the scholars. It is befitting that the
people of knowledge be concerned
and have good intentions for their students, that they look
towards the students with an eye of love, that they surround
them with their desire for good for
them, and surround them with care for them, so that they grow in an upright manner
and do not
The instruction to take care of the Students of Knowledge given by Allaah's Messenger
alayhi wa sallam)
Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) gave counsel for the students of knowledge to be
well. Aboo Sa'eed al-Khudree said, "Welcome to the admonition given by Allaah's Messenger
(sallallahu alayhi wa sallam).
Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) used to counsel us concerning
you (meaning the students of knowledge)."86
The Companions were likewise
The Companions (radiyallaahu 'anhum) used to apply this admonition that was given to
ibn Ziyaad said, "'Alee ibn Abee Taalib took hold of my hand and took me out towards some
ground. When we reached the desert area, he sat down, took a breath and then said, "O
Kumayl ibn Ziyaad! The hearts are
vessels, so the best of them are the most receptive of them.
Preserve what I am going to say to you."' And he mentioned
a lengthy advice.87
So consider how the Chief of the Believers gave the advice to his student, al-Kumayl ibn Ziyaad an-Nakha'ee.
The fact that he spoke pleasantly with him, face to face, took hold of his hand and then
took him along to a place
suitable for admonition, to open ground. This `open ground (jabbaan),'
could be just an open desert area; a place where
a person can be alone, able to consider, to think
and reflect. Because the heart becomes free when one goes to such a
Indeed Allah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) was caused to love seclusion at the start of
It is reported from 'Aa'ishah(radiyallaahu 'anha), the Mother of the Believers, that she said,
"The start of the Revelation
to Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) were the true dreams. So
he had not used to see any dream except that
it occurred just as clearly as the dawn breaks. Then
solitude was made beloved to him, so he used to go off alone to the
Cave of Hiraa and he would
worship in it for a number of nights."88
85 Daleelul-Faalihaan of Ibn Alaan, (1/278).
Reported by al-Haakim (1/88), al-'Alaa'ee in Bughyatul Multamis, (p.28) and ar-Raamahurmuzee in Al-Muhaddithul-Faadil,
21). It was declared saheeh by our Shaykh (may Allah protect him) in As-Saheehah, (no. 280).
87 And refer necessarily
to my book, Al-Is'aad Bidhikr Fawaa'id Wasiyyah Ameeril-Mu'mineen 'Alee ibn Abee Taalib lil-Kumayl
ibn Ziyaad. [Trans.
note: The English reader may refer to the forthcoming book Min Wasaayas -Salaf compiled by Shaikh
Saleem as it includes
this advice in full., Salafi Publications, Birmingham, UK]
88 Reported by al-Bukhaaree, (Eng. trans. vol. 1, no. 3).
Or the open ground' which 'Alee took his student to was
a graveyard.89 Since that is a place where
one is reminded of the Hereafter. So whichever of these places it was, then
he alerted him to the
importance of what he was going to relate to him, and he commanded him to comprehend and
So this is the prophetic methodology in teaching, just the way in which Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu
wa sallam) used to teach, and did so with 'Abdullaah ibn 'Abbaas (may Allaah be pleased with them
both), when he said
to him, "O young man, I am going to teach you some words ..." the hadeeth.90
Some Pearls from the Sayings of the People
Al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee said in his book, Al-Jaami' li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadaabis-Saami',
"Chapter: The narrator of hadeeth should show respect to the students of knowledge and should
tolerate the students
in a good manner and he should be mild with them." He mentioned a number
of headings in this chapter, and we shall mention
the most important of them.
That he should give respect to the elders and the people with
honour the nobles of the people and those with lineage.
He should honour whoever is the head amongst his people and is
influential amongst his people.
He should give respect to those people who come from a different
place and draw
them close and that he should receive and welcome them.
He should have modesty and humility towards the students.
should treat them with good manners.
He should be gentle with those who have a rough and coarse
from the pearls of his words in another of his books, Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih, (2/110) is his
saying under the heading,
`A mention of the manners of the scholar and the manners that are
essential for him and which he must apply with regard
to his students and companions. He should
choose from the traits those which are the finest; and take from manners the
most excellent of
them. So he should apply these manners and characteristics with those who are far and those that
close to him. He should apply this with the foreigner and those that have lineage. And he should
avoid the ways of the
ignorant people, he should avoid the manners of the common folk and the
And he said under the heading
(2/113): Applying modesty, humility, mildness and gentle speech:
"And it is befitting that he should accustom his tongue
to being mild in his speech, being gentle in
questioning and answering. This should be applied generally to the whole
of the ummah of the
Muslims and to the people of the Dhimmah."
And he said (2/116~120) under the heading: The scholars
accepting and welcoming students and
showing them that he is pleased to receive them:
89 [Trans. note: Because in
Arabic the word `jabbaan' can refer to either a desert or a graveyard].
90 Authentic, as I have explained in Saheeh Kitaabil-Adhkaar
wa da'eefihi, (no. 1218/1000).
"And the scholar should serve his companions himself in
such a way as will cause them to have
affection and cause their hearts to have love for him." And he said, "It is befitting
that he notices
and has concern for the absence of his students when they are absent, and asks about those who
And he said (2/139) under the heading: The attention the scholars should give to the different levels
"It is recommended that the scholar should be aware of the different levels of his students in their
and should keep in mind their excellence. He should make clear their standing so that
the people can refer to them when
anything happens to him, and can take knowledge from them."
And he said (2/140), "And if it becomes clear to the scholar
that one of his companions is
outstanding in his knowledge and in his good understanding of fiqh then it is permissible
him to particularise him and to give him preference over the others."
Some fine points and some important landmarks
This covers the following fine points:
(i) The fact that the chain of narration is something that continues. Al-Alaa'ee
said in his
book, Bughyatul-Multamiss on page 23, "To proceed. Then Allaah, the Exalted and Most High, and
is for Him and all favours are from Him, has favoured this noble ummah with the
connected chain of narration. It is through
this that the later ones of this ummah have reported from
the earlier ones, the Sunnah of their Prophet (sallallahu alayhi
wa sallam) and the explanation of what
he was upon.
This is one of his miracles that he indicated and he promised
his ummah that this is something that
will be preserved, and he gave counsel with regard to the students of knowledge
that they were to
be treated kindly, that they should be helped to attain their aim and that they should be aided. The
Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said, `You will hear, and people will hear from you, and from those
from you others will hear from them. '"
(ii) An Encouragement for travelling to seek knowledge. Since it is reported
in some of the
preceding reports of Aboo Sa'eed al-Khudree, that the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said, "There
will come to you a people who seek knowledge, so when you see them then say, `Welcome, welcome to
the admonition given
by Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam),' and satisfy them."
92 I said to al-Hakam
(one of the sub-narrators)
what does `... satisfy them ...' mean? He said `Teach them.'
And in his book, Ar-Rihlah fee talabil hadeeth (Journeying
to Seek Hadeeth), al-Khateeb
al-Baghdaadee quoted many excellent points in this regard. It is famous from the people of
knowledge how they had humility, how they had eagerness to convey knowledge to their students,
those who hastened
towards them from the different parts of the earth to drink from their pure
(iii) The scholar should devote
himself to the students of knowledge. And there were scholars
who accepted students with generosity and with generous
manners. They accepted those students
of knowledge who came to them and benefited from them and this is something indicated
saying of Allaah, the Most High, to His Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam):
91 Reported by Aboo Daawood
(no. 3695), Ahmad (1/321), Ibn Hibbaan (no. 77, Mawaarid), al-Haakim (1/95) by way of
'Abdullaah ibn 'Abdullaah ibn Sa'eed
ibn Jubayr: from Ibn 'Abbaas, from the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam). Al-Haakim
declared it saheeh to the standard
of the two shaykhs. I say: The two shaykhs do not quote any narrations from 'Abdullaah
ibn 'Abdullaah, but he is reliable
92 Refer to Saheeh Sunan Ibn Maajah, (no. 201).
And by the Mercy of Allaah you were gentle with them.
And if you had been
severe and harsh hearted they would have broken away and left you. So
pass over their short-comings
and seek forgiveness for them and consult
them in the affairs.' Soorah Aali-Imraan (3):159.
So since it is the case
that the Lord of all the creation advised His Messenger (sallallahu alayhi wa
sallam) to treat his companions in a good
manner, then indeed the students of knowledge are in
great need of the shelter of a merciful scholar, and in need of the
best care, of kindliness,
friendliness and love to encompass them and mildness. A scholar who does not distress them and
harm them when they suffer from ignorance, weakness and deficiencies.
They are in need of a large heart that will
give to them and does not need that they should give to
him. One who will carry their worries and not bother them with
his concerns, (one) who is such that
they find that he takes care of them and has sympathy with them.
So because of
this a person will hardly hear a part of all of this advice for the benefit of the students
of knowledge and see the great
care and attention that is to be given to the students of knowledge,
except that it makes him want to leap forward and
to be a part of this sublime life of knowledge that
will produce fruits, as Allaah wills, beginning from its great beginning
that lies with the people of
Hadeeth, those upon the way of the Pious Predecessors, in order that the glory this ummah
should be returned to it and that the hope that it has be realised. We ask Allaah that He grant us
see that memorable day.
CHOOSING THE SHAIKHS AND
SCHOLARS WITH WHOM YOU SHOULD
In the saying of Allaah's Messenger (sallallahu alayhi
wa sallam) to 'Umar Ibn al-Khattaab (radiyallaahu
'anhu), "This was Jibreel, he came to teach you your Religion," is an
indication for the student of
knowledge to turn his face toward the people of knowledge, the wise and learned scholars
whose fame for having taqwaa is widespread, whose reliability is established, those whose
uprightness upon the
Religion is known.
This Knowledge is your Religion
The Pious Predecessors have indicated this point that is such that
it rescues from ignorance and
protects those who follow and apply it from misguidance. The noble taabi'ee Muhammad Ibn
Seereen said, "Indeed this knowledge is the Religion so look and see from whom you arc taking your
is because the knowledge is carried by the trustworthy ones. So it is right and proper
that this is whom it is taken from.
Just as Aboo Moosaa 'Eesaa ibn Sabeeh said, "It is
authentic from the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) that he said,
This knowledge will be
carried in every generation by the trustworthy ones, those who will repel from it the changes of
going beyond bounds, the misinterpretations of the ignorant, and the false claims of the liars.
correct way of knowledge is that it should be taken from those who have this as their way and
it is befitting that you distinguish between the scholars of the people of Sunnah
and those of the people of bid'ah (innovation)
just as Muhammad Ibn Seereen (may Allaah have mercy
on him) said, "They had not used to ask about the chain of narration
but when the fitnah 96 occurred
they said, `Name your men to us.' So as for the people of the Sunnah then their narrations
be accepted, and as for the people of innovation, their narrations would not he accepted."97
Likewise it is
befitting that one distinguishes the people of understanding and accepts from them,
because every knowledge has its people
who are known with it and known through it. Maalik Ibn
Anas (may Allaah have mercy on him) said, "This knowledge is Religion
so look to see from whom you
take your Religion. I met seventy people who would say, `So and so said Allaah's Messenger
(sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) said that ...' (i.e., men from the Taabi'een) at the pillars of the mosque,
and he indicated
that the mosque of the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) but I didn't take anything
from them. But if one of them
were given some wealth he would have proved trustworthy. Because
they were not from the people of this affair; and when
Muhammad ibn Muslim Ibn 'Ubaydullaah ibn
'Abdullaah Ibn Shihaab (az-Zuhree) comes, the people crowd around his door."98
93 From the introduction of Muslim to his Saheeh, with an authentic chain of narration.
94 Hasan due to its supports
as I have shown in a separate treatise.
95 Al-Jaami' li Akhlaaqir-Raawee wa Aadaabis-Saami', (1/129).
96 i.e., the
fitnah of the liar, al-Mukhtaar ibn 'Ubayd ath-Thaqafee who claimed revelation and offered large sums of money
people to fabricate ahadeeth. His appearance was foretold by the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) in his saying,
will come amongst Thaqeef a great liar and a great murderer." Reported by Muslim (Eng. trans. vol. 4, p. 1351, no.
He perished in 67 H [Trans. note].
97 Reported by Muslim in the introduction to his `saheeh' (1/15) with an authentic
chain of narration.
98 Al-Faqeeh wal-Mutafaqqih, (2/98)
Some Pearls from the Sayings of the People of Knowledge
This point has been indicated by the people of knowledge in their works in order to protect and to
prepare for the
future so that this knowledge would not fall into the arms of the false claimants,
"Those people whose tree sprouted in
a barren land, those who compete for prominence before they
have matured, those who turn into raisins before they have
become grapes, those who throw
themselves upon the station of knowledge to give verdicts and to author works, and those
intrude upon the pinnacle belonging to the trustworthy predecessors of this ummah. So these people
in the courtyards belonging to knowledge, and are only intent upon demolishing
its sanctity and tearing down its protective
And the boldness of these people has only been increased by the common folk and their likes
circles in amazement listening to their stories with delight. Al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee
said in, Al-Faqeeh wal Mutafaqqih
(2/96), "It is befitting for the student that he should
turn his attention to those scholars who are famous for their
practise of the Religion. Those who are
known for their good and for their repute upon good in the Religion." Then he
said, "He should be
such that he is characterised by patience, mildness, modesty, and being kind, mild and tolerant with
his companions, but who speaks the truth and gives sincere advice to the creation, and the rest of
attributes and beautiful characteristics."
And in his excellent book, AL-Jaami' li Akhlaaqir-Raawee (1/126~137) he placed
a number of
chapters which we shall mention:
The levels of narrators are not equal in their knowledge, so precedence
should be given to those who have a higher chain of narration. If the scholars
have chains of the same length and
the student only wants to hear from
some of them, he should pick the most famous of them for having sought
those who are pointed out for their precision and understanding.
And if they are the same in their chains of narration
understanding, then he should choose those who are noble and have lineage -
they have greater right.
of this refers to those who have the precondition of being known to be
straight and upright in their Religion, (those)
for whom it is established that
they are trustworthy and free from innovations. As for one who is not of this
then you must turn away from him and not hear from him.
The scholars are agreed that hearing narration's from one about
whom it is
established that he is a sinner, then it is not allowed to hear from him, and
flagrant sin (fisq) will
be established by many affairs not particular to the field
of hadeeth. As for those particular to hadeeth, then from them
for example is
that he fabricates texts of hadeeth and attributes them to Allaah's Messenger
(sallallahu alayhi wa
sallam) or fabricates their chains of narration. It is said that
the very start of the investigation of hadeeth was due
to this reason. Also
from these reasons is that a person claims to hear from one whom he never
met, this is why the
scholars carefully reported the dates narrators were born
and died. In this way narrations were found for scholars from
those they were
too young to have met. They also carefully recorded the attributes of scholars
of hadeeth and their
appearance and circumstances and through this a
number of narrators were uncovered.
Regarding other narrators, then
even though they were free of having
fabricated narrations, and from claiming to have heard from those they did
meet, and avoided those characteristics that destroy trustworthiness, yet
they did not possess written copies of the narrations
they heard and so they
had to narrate from memory alone. Then it is not correct to depend upon
their narrations until
well-grounded people of knowledge of narrations bear
witness in their favour-that they are from those who did
knowledge, take care of it, were precise about it and carefully memorised it.
Then his precision and care
is checked by mixing up narrations as a test for
If the narrator of hadeeth is from the people of innovated sects
that conflict with the truth, then narration's are not to be taken from him
even if he has studied and memorised.
Beware of wasting or losing the knowledge
It is befitting for the students of the sharee'ah knowledge that they should
be aware of the true
reality of the affair, to be aware from whom they are taking their Religion. They should not seek
from the people of Innovation who will mislead them while they do not realise, because he (sallallahu
sallam) said, "From the signs of the Last Hour is that knowledge will be sought from 'the small
Students of Knowledge! Awaken! Because this knowledge is Religion and be aware of whom you
take your Religion from. Have
I not conveyed the message? O Allaah! Bear witness.
Splinters of Gold with Regard to the Manners of Seeking Knowledge
This is a poem that is cane of the best of the poems that I have seen quoting the manners of
learning and the manners
of acquiring knowledge. I saw that I should quote it here due to its beauty
and due to the benefits I hoped would come
about through it for the one who reads my book and
hoping that Allaah would benefit myself and him through it:
that knowledge comes about through learning, through memorisation, precision and
understanding. Knowledge may be granted
to a young person and an old person may be prevented
For indeed a person is according to two small parts
of the body (i.e., his heart and his tongue) and
not according to his legs and his arms-rather his tongue, and his heart
that is built into his chest.
That is an amazing part of creation. So knowledge comes about through understanding and
and lessons, and through reflecting and through discussing.
So it may be the case that a person attains great
memorisation and he can quote the text and
repeat the wording but in anything else he has no share of that which the well
It may be the case that a person has great eagerness and love for knowledge, and for
but his heart is dull-witted and he is unable to memorise and narrate. He has no way
to quote that which is narrated,
whereas another person is granted without effort memorisation of
that which occurs in the chain of narration. It agitates
his heart without troubling his eyes and he
99 [Ibn al-Mubarak said that '... the small ones ...' (al-Asaaghir) means
the people of innovation, see' As-Saheehah no. 695.
Trans. note]. Reported by 'Abdullaah ibn al-Mubaarak in Az-Zuhd (no.61),
al-Laalikaa'ee in Sharh Usoolul-I'tiqaad Ahlis-Sunnah
wal-Jamaa'ah (no.102) and al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee in Jaami li-Akhlaaqir-Raawee
wa Aadaabis-Saami' (1/137), by
way of Ibn Lahee'ah, from Bakr ibn Sawaadah from: Aboo Umayyah al-Jumahee: from the Prophet
(sallallahu alayhi wa
sallam). I say: This is a saheeh chain of narration, since the narrations of Ibn Lahee'ah are authentic
if one of the 'Abdullaah's
narrate from him, and Ibn al-Mubaarak is one of them. Along with this is the fact that Ibn
Lahee'ah is not alone in reporting
it, rather Sa'eed ibn Abee Ayyoob supports his narration, reported by al-Khateeb al-Baghdaadee
(1/137), and he is fully
reliable and trustworthy. It also has a witness from the hadeeth of Ibn Mas'ood (radiyallaahu
'anhu) that has the ruling of
having come from the Prophet (sallallahu alayhi wa sallam) since it is something that cannot
be said upon the basis of opinion
and personal deduction. And its wording is, "The people will continue upon good as long
as the knowledge comes to them from
the Companions of Muhammad and their greater folk. But when the knowledge comes to
them from their smaller ones, then that
is when they will be destroyed." Reported by Ibn al-Mubaraak (no. 851), al-Laalikaa'ee
(no. 101) and others).
has no need of stores of books. So seek the knowledge
and seek it in a good manner and knowledge
will not come about except through manners.
The beneficial manners are
fine behaviour, and in too much speech there is hatred. So for as long as
you live try to attain good manners, you will
be praiseworthy for as long as you remain. And if a
question appears amongst the people, something well-known from knowledge
or something newly
raised up, then don't be the first person to give an answer to it, until you have seen that somebody
before you has spoken about that.
Because how many examples there have been before us of people in haste who speak
understanding and who speak erroneously, and this has earned them ridicule in the gatherings with
of understanding and those who strive. Silence is truly a better adornment for you if you
do not have certain knowledge.
And if you are uncertain about a matter about which you are asked,
then say, `For that which you ask about I do not have
any narration.' So this is half of knowledge
with the scholars, the wise people have not ceased saying this.
of being pleased and amazed with the excellence of your own opinion. And beware of
giving an answer to something which
will be a mistake. How many answers have been followed by
regret, so seek the benefit of silence and being safe, for knowledge
is an ocean, the limit of it is very
far away, it has no end point that you can seek to reach and you have not gathered
all of the
knowledge, certainly not, not even a tenth of it even if you collected all that you had. That which
for you is far more than that which you know, and even the fastest horse sometimes
And if you hear something
that you do not understand then ask for its meaning. The saying is two
sayings, a saying which you will understand, and
a saying which you will not understand. Every
saying will have an answer covering that which is false and that which is
true. For speech there is a
beginning and an end so understand the both of them and let your mind be attentive.
not hasten to speak and do not hasten to return it until it leads you to that which follows on from
it. It may be the
case that the people of virtue are rendered unable to give an answer to questions
they are asked, and therefore withhold
with silence from answering when doubt comes to them
regarding the answer. And even if a saying is counted by the common
people to be like pure silver,
then silence is from the purest gold.
So understand this, may Allaah guide you to the
manners of seeking knowledge."100
100 Jaami' Bayaanil-Ilm wa Fadlihi, (1/146-148) adapted slightly.
May Allaah grant ud the best conclusion and grant
us more besides. This is what I have been able to
gather together in this short time and I ask Allaah that he conveys
it to those people whom it befits
and those who know its value, and who hasten to accept it and who call for it to become
And I know that this topic needs further elaboration, further breaking down, further joining,
and exactness. However it is just an indication for those people who have been struck with
inability to distinguish and
thus have become mouthpieces for the claims of the deviant sects and for
the beguiling and erroneous calls. Those who
think that they are upon something but they are not
upon anything at all, and the person who does not have something cannot
give anything, even if a
person may feel satisfied with something which he has not been given and may make claims to have
that which he does not possess.
There is not space here in this conclusion except to repeat what Ibn 'Abdul-Barr said
in his valuable
book, Jaami' Bayaanil-'Ilm wa Fadlihi on page 6, "And I love that the one guided to it should
it. And if the scholars had left aside gathering the reports and checking out the narrations,
and had left the proof for
every type of affair just as a chapter in a book and had left every type of
knowledge just as a section of a book, then
wisdom would have been nullified and knowledge would
have been lost and passed away.
And even though a large part
of the knowledge has passed away because due attention was not
given, due to little care, due to pre-occupation with the
worldly life and due to rushing for the
worldly life-yet still, even so, Allaah causes His Religion to remain through
a people even if they are
few: those who protect the fundamentals for this ummah and who distinguish and check it's details.
This is a bounty and a blessing from Allaah.
The people will always remain upon good as long as the first person lives
long enough to teach the
next one-because the passing away of knowledge comes about through the passing away of the
How Perfect You are O Allaah and free from all defects
All praise is due to You
I testify that none has the right
to be worshipped but You
I seek Your forgiveness and turn repentantly to You